Redwall Choose Your Own Adventure

[James Gryphon]

This is counterintuitive, but B. The second command is obviously a much better fighter than we are, and making a stand isn't likely to get very far. Maybe if we pretend to be helpless, we can lure him in and catch him with his guard down.

[Lady Amber]

B. ^

[rrrrr]

We need one more tiebreaker.

[Rainshadow]

  I think I'll side with James and Amber on this one in saying B.  The Second Command is clearly a skilled warrior, so we don't stand a chance against him in one-on-one combat.

[rrrrr]

You pretend to faint and open your eyes a little bit. You see a tankard of "Extra Strong Shrewbeer" next to your feet. The Second Command waves a strange nine-pointed star around Oakscut several times around. Oakscut opens his eyes, and the air around him goes dark. What do you do?

<A> Jump overboard!
<B> Throw the tankard of "Extra Strong Shrewbeer" at Oakscut
<C> Throw the tankard of "Extra Strong Shrewbeer" at the Second Command

[Delthion]

I would want to learn more about this strange star.

[James Gryphon]

A is tempting, but we don't know how far away the shore is, and I don't like the idea of abandoning an ally. C is obvious: in fact, too obvious.

I say B. The extra strong shrewbeer will make Oakscut extra strong, so that he can K.O. the second command with one kick.  

Or maybe it'll at least rouse him, or if the "nine-pointed star" is some magic thing, interfere with that.

Maybe I'm overthinking this, but it wouldn't be the first time that the obvious and seemingly correct choice was wrong.

[Delthion]

Oh, I forgot that Oakscut was our ally.

I change my vote to B.

[Rainshadow]

  I think I'll go with B as well.

[James Gryphon]

Bump?

[Lady Amber]

I guess I'll go with B. At first I would've chosen C, because the tankard might knock the vermin guy out, and I didn't really get how just because the shrewbeer was "extra-strong" it would make the person who drank it really strong. But, I guess it might revive Oakscut, and maybe if it bonks him on the head it might do the same.

[Lady Amber]

*Bumps* Hello?