My top ten saddest deaths are
1 Rose
2 Methuselah
3 Bragoon & Saro
4 Mother Mellus
5 All the guys killed in the wreck of the Sayna
6 Shogg
7 The Mask
8 Skarlath
9 Felldoh
10 Luke, or Ranguvar Foeseeker
What about you?
The only two deaths that made me choke up were Finbarr Galedeep's and The Mask's (both otters, interesting) good thing Warthorn killed Cludd in a horrible way. Rose, Methusela and Mellus's deaths were also sad. Is Slipp (the one who killed Mellus) the only rat to kill a badger in the series?
Yes. That was really weird.
Nice job, i agree on most. My top 5 are
1. Rose-this was so sad, i thought she and martin would be together after the battle
2. The Mask-right after his entrance into the book he became my favorite character
3. Feldoh-the way he just died on the battlefield kind of...annoyed me. If he was going to die, i wanted him to die, by killing Badrang
4.Methuselah-i did not think he was going to die, so i was really surprised when Chickenhound killed him, he and Matthias were really close
5. Finbarr Galedeep
I have now read many more books, here are all the saddest ones:
Finbarr Galedeep: I think I actually did have tears coming down for that one
Cregga: It was so nice, but so sad. I hope to die as peaceful as that
The Mask: I loved The Mask, so this one hurt
Rose: Obviously
Methusela: I liked him a lot
Abbot Mortimer: He was, and is one of my favorite redwall characters
The crew of they Sayna: To die just so disgustingly, smashed into a boat while sleeping by a disgusting stoat
Friar Skurpul: He WAS SO NICE! :'(