who would win?

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

although i don't count my vote, i would go with Mokkan. You see, just because he didn't fight much in the story doesnt mean he was a coward. Mokkan was a leader, whereas Zwilt was second to the Sable Quaen. Zwilt was stuck  doing the dirty work, which is why we see him fight more than Mokkan did.

Agreed. Mokkan didnae fight az much merely becauze 'e found ozer much better vayz at accomplizhin' 'iz goalz zen an onvard frontal azzault. Vot dae ye zink vid 'ave 'appened if ze Marlfoxez 'ad juzt valked up tae Redwall an' attacked? Zey vid probably 'ave been zlain an' zen vhere vid zey be, eh? An' ah vizh zat ze ztory 'adnae juzt killed 'im like zey did. It vid 'ave been major if zey 'ad 'im gae dovn fightin' or zummat like zat!

[Captain Tammo]

who do you guys think should be in the next fight? let me know here or send me a PM!

[Dannflower Reguba]

although i don't count my vote, i would go with Mokkan. You see, just because he didn't fight much in the story doesnt mean he was a coward. Mokkan was a leader, whereas Zwilt was second to the Sable Quaen. Zwilt was stuck  doing the dirty work, which is why we see him fight more than Mokkan did.

Agreed. Mokkan didnae fight az much merely becauze 'e found ozer much better vayz at accomplizhin' 'iz goalz zen an onvard frontal azzault. Vot dae ye zink vid 'ave 'appened if ze Marlfoxez 'ad juzt valked up tae Redwall an' attacked? Zey vid probably 'ave been zlain an' zen vhere vid zey be, eh? An' ah vizh zat ze ztory 'adnae juzt killed 'im like zey did. It vid 'ave been major if zey 'ad 'im gae dovn fightin' or zummat like zat!

Jaques probably killed him like that so at least he'd have his dignity, Mokkan was a ##:1031 fox, BTW, his plans involved the same ratio of fighting to tactics that pretty much every other warlord who attempted Redwall did, he just dis-included himself from the fighting.

[Tam and Martin]

although i don't count my vote, i would go with Mokkan. You see, just because he didn't fight much in the story doesnt mean he was a coward. Mokkan was a leader, whereas Zwilt was second to the Sable Quaen. Zwilt was stuck  doing the dirty work, which is why we see him fight more than Mokkan did.

Agreed. Mokkan didnae fight az much merely becauze 'e found ozer much better vayz at accomplizhin' 'iz goalz zen an onvard frontal azzault. Vot dae ye zink vid 'ave 'appened if ze Marlfoxez 'ad juzt valked up tae Redwall an' attacked? Zey vid probably 'ave been zlain an' zen vhere vid zey be, eh? An' ah vizh zat ze ztory 'adnae juzt killed 'im like zey did. It vid 'ave been major if zey 'ad 'im gae dovn fightin' or zummat like zat!

Jaques probably killed him like that so at least he'd have his dignity, Mokkan was a [female] fox, BTW, his plans involved the same ratio of fighting to tactics that pretty much every other warlord who attempted Redwall did, he just dis-included himself from the fighting.

He wasn't a female.

[Captain Tammo]

Ok let's get back to the debate. Remember the scene is a dark night in Mossflower woods. Although Zwilt the shade was a sneaky creature, I feel like none could compare to a marlfox's stealth. Marlfoxes have been able to "dissapear" right in front of a creature's face! Zwilt may know The tricks, but Mokkan invented them.

[Tam and Martin]

Ok let's get back to the debate. Remember the scene is a dark night in Mossflower woods. Although Zwilt the shade was a sneaky creature, I feel like none could compare to a marlfox's stealth. Marlfoxes have been able to "dissapear" right in front of a creature's face! Zwilt may know The tricks, but Mokkan invented them.

That is sooooo true!

[The Shade]

Agreed.

[Captain Tammo]

The winner is Zwilt the Shade!

New matchup!

Groats the Flame from Eulalia!
Vs.
Sunflash the Mace from Outcast of Redwall

Who Would Win?

Next matchup will be a fan-submitted one

[rachel25]

who this should be fun

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

'ov did Zvilt vin ze lazt vone? Ach! Viz regardz tae ziz next vone, ah'm goin' tae remain neutral 'ere an' zay zat zey vere boz pretty major. 'ovever, zat vid be a fight zat ah vidnae vant tae mizz! Goraz'z Tung v.z Zunflazh'z mace!

[Leatho Shellhound]

I think Sunflash the Mace would win, he seemed to have more battle experience, Gorath grew up more as a farmer than Sunflash. Even though  Sunflash did become a farmer badger lord at the end.

[Tam and Martin]

Sunflash. Leatho got all the reasons I would say are right.

[Blaggut]

With Tsarmina you could just get an ol' bucket of water and throw it on her.

HIAG!!! Why did you not speak in your awesome language   

[Tam and Martin]

With Tsarmina you could just get an ol' bucket of water and throw it on her.

HIAG!!! Why did you not speak in your awesome language   

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

With Tsarmina you could just get an ol' bucket of water and throw it on her.

HIAG!!! Why did you not speak in your awesome language   

Zat iz an' older pozt, vhen ah 'adnae quite gotten tae me current accent yet. Ach, tiz amazin' 'ov far tiz gotten!