The Short List

[BrookSkimmer]

Here are the results of the tournament rounds for those who don't want to read the details... or just for those who want to see it organized like me:

Round 1:
Skyblade (Razer) vs. WONWILL (Luke)
Daniel of Redwall (Cluny) vs. WONWILL (Coal)
Rainshadow (Lonna Bowstripe) vs. Daniel of Redwall (Ballista the Fierce)
Matthias 720 (Barfell) vs. Tiria Wildlough (Slassen)
Danflorreguba (Danflower) vs. Gorath (Jukkarus)
Round 1 Danflor (Danndil) vs. Skipper (folgrim)
HeadInAnotherGalaxy (Mokkan) vs. Rainshadow (Shadow)
HeadInAnotherGalaxy (Aldar) vs. Warrior of Mossflower (Rakkety Tam)
Danflorreguba (Rarou) vs. Warrior of Mossflower (Tarwin)

[Lutra]

I'd highly recommend anyone who participated in this to read the long list.  You will get a better sense of how we are judging the posts...and you'll find that all three of us look at different stuff.  Brook definitely focuses more on how Redwall-like the post is, where I flat out ignore that and want to see you using a weapon, giving creative detail to how you do so.

If you haven't read them yet, I'd do so before round 2 so you can even make better posts this time around and impress all of the judges.

[BrookSkimmer]

Well, I guess I shall clarify how I judge so as not to be boxed in...

I may have made more comments on staying in character but that does not mean I'm ignoring the other sides of RP dueling. I'm won over by description of character and scene, developing the character you are RPing, proper and believable use of weapons, and making your posts portray a sense of reality (reality based in the made up world of Redwall )

Anyhoo, I supposed that would be a FYI for those of you who have made it round 2.

[BrookSkimmer]

The Short List Returns:

Skipper (Folgrim) vs HeadInAnotherGalaxy (Mokkan)
Rainshadow (Lonna Bowstripe) vs. Tiria Wildlough (Slassen)
Matthias 720 (Matthias the Warrior) vs. Skyblade (Razer)
Warrior of Mossflower (Tarwin) vs. Danflorreguba (Danflower)
Daniel of Redwall (Cluny)>>> advances to Round 3

There you go! Please take the time to read over the full results as well.

Also, the only characters we have left are "favorites" from the Redwall books. Looks like favorites win over fans. Now we just have to wait and see who the Champion will be...

[BrookSkimmer]

The Shorter List... Sequel of... The Short List

HeadInAnotherGalaxy (Mokkan) vs. Danflorreguba (Danflower)
Matthias 720 (Matthias the Warrior) vs. Daniel of Redwall (Cluny)

Taa daaa! Good job everyone! Some of these were really hard to judge!

[BrookSkimmer]

Final Results:

Here is how this round was judged:
Instead of using results for each duel to determine winners, I have totaled up the votes from each judge to determine the winners. So, out of 9 votes possible here is how the results worked out:

Matthias720: 4
Rainshadow:2
Danflorreguba:2
Draw: 1

So, our grand champion is: Matthias720
Tie for first runner up goes to: Rainshadow and Danflorreguba

Prize art and prize banners will be out within the next two weeks!