Text only | Text with Images

Redwall Abbey

General Boards => Forum Games => Topic started by: Captain Tammo on September 25, 2011, 02:42:23 PM

Title: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 25, 2011, 02:42:23 PM
Ok so the last game was a lot of fun so we wanted to start a new one. There are some additional rules this time though:
1. By voting for your favorite book, you add (+1) next to it and increase your book's score by one, then you decrease another book's score by putting a (-1) next to it and taking off one of their points.
2. You can vote as many times as you want, but not twice in a row. So you must wait for someone else to post before you post again.
3.you don't have to stay with the same book the whole time.
4.There is a score limit at 10 once your book reaches 10, you don't add anymore to it until it's score is decreased by another player. However, you can still (-1) other books, just not add to your score.
5.if you are the one to eliminate a book, please cross it out. For example:
Rakkety Tam
6. Ok that's it! Hope you have fun and may the best book win!

Redwall 5
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 6 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 5
Triss 5
Loamhedge 5
Rakkety Tam 4 (-1)
High Rhulain 5
Eulalia! 5
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 25, 2011, 03:26:10 PM
Redwall 5
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 6
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 5
Triss 4 (-1)
Loamhedge 5
Rakkety Tam 4
High Rhulain 5
Eulalia! 5
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 25, 2011, 03:28:51 PM
Redwall 5
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 5
Triss 4
Loamhedge 5
Rakkety Tam 3 (-1)
High Rhulain 5
Eulalia! 5
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Folgrimeo on September 25, 2011, 06:27:25 PM
Redwall 5
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 6 (+1)
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4 (-1)
Rakkety Tam 3
High Rhulain 5
Eulalia! 5
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 25, 2011, 06:37:13 PM
Redwall 6 (+1)
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4
Rakkety Tam 3
High Rhulain 5
Eulalia! 4 (-1)
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on September 25, 2011, 08:11:51 PM
Redwall 6 (+1)
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6 (+1)
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4
Rakkety Tam 3
High Rhulain 4 (-1)
Eulalia! 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: HeadInAnotherGalaxy on September 25, 2011, 11:31:38 PM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 5
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4
Rakkety Tam 4 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 3 (-1)
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 25, 2011, 11:52:37 PM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6 (+1)
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4
Rakkety Tam 4
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 3 
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: HeadInAnotherGalaxy on September 26, 2011, 12:03:47 AM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 4
Rakkety Tam 5 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 2 (-1)
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 26, 2011, 12:59:45 AM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 6 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 3 (-1)
Rakkety Tam 5
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 2
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: HeadInAnotherGalaxy on September 26, 2011, 01:26:27 AM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 3
Rakkety Tam 6 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 1 (-1)
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 26, 2011, 01:35:54 AM
Redwall 7 (+1)
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 3
Rakkety Tam 6
High Rhulain 4
Eulalia! 0 (-1)
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: HeadInAnotherGalaxy on September 26, 2011, 01:49:38 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 6
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 2 (-1)
Rakkety Tam 7 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 26, 2011, 02:09:48 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 7
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 7 (+1)
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 2 
Rakkety Tam 6 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 26, 2011, 02:14:34 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 7
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 5 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 26, 2011, 02:24:42 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 8 (+1)
Taggerung 6
Triss 4
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 4 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 26, 2011, 09:24:00 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 6 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
Triss 3 (-1)
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 4
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 26, 2011, 01:42:04 PM
Redwall 8 (+1)
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 4 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 4
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 26, 2011, 03:16:19 PM
Redwall 8
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 4
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 3 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 26, 2011, 04:28:41 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 8
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 3
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 26, 2011, 08:28:32 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 9 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 2 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 26, 2011, 10:11:29 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 9
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 10 (+1)
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 1 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on September 26, 2011, 10:12:50 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 1 (-1) eleminated
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 26, 2011, 10:16:19 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 27, 2011, 12:15:02 AM
Quote from: rakkety tam on September 26, 2011, 10:12:50 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10 (+1)
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
Rakkety Tam 1 (-1) eleminated
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 5

Never would've guessed you'd be the one to eliminate Rakkety Tam haha. Then again, you did say you didn't want it in the competition this time.

Anyway,

Redwall 9
Mossflower 5 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 6 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 3
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 27, 2011, 09:58:04 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 7 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 2 (-1)
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 27, 2011, 11:38:08 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 4 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 7 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 2
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 27, 2011, 01:39:39 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 4 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 8 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 7
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 1 (-1)
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 27, 2011, 03:16:24 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 4 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 7
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 1
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 27, 2011, 03:52:29 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 4 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 9 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 7
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Triss 0 (-1)
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 6
The Rogue Crew 5

Triss has been eliminated
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 27, 2011, 06:02:38 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 8 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 7
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 7 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 27, 2011, 08:01:40 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 3 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 8 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 28, 2011, 12:48:07 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 1 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 01:29:37 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 28, 2011, 01:39:34 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 3 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 9 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 01:47:06 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 3
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 6 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 8 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 28, 2011, 02:26:17 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 2 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 2
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 28, 2011, 03:19:07 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 3 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3 Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 1 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 5
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on September 28, 2011, 04:41:22 AM
My goodness! Three books eliminated already! This should be a short game...

Redwall 10
Mossflower 3
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 6 (+1)
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 1
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4 (-1)
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 28, 2011, 09:38:31 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 6
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
Loamhedge 0 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5

Loamhedge has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 10:13:36 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 7 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 28, 2011, 10:46:26 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 5
The Legend of Luke 8 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 11:30:21 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 8 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 4 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 28, 2011, 01:41:50 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 4
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9 (-1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 01:55:09 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 9 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 4
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 02:09:29 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 4
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 03:05:02 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 3 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 8
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 03:13:39 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 2 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 9 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 03:28:43 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 1 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 6 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 03:35:52 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 0 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 6

Marlfox has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on September 28, 2011, 03:37:58 PM
Sad day. Poor Marlfox...

Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 7 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3 (-1)
The Sable Quean 10
The Rogue Crew 6
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 28, 2011, 03:41:31 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 7 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on September 28, 2011, 03:43:48 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 3
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 2 (-1)
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 28, 2011, 03:46:43 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 2 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 3
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3 (+1)
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 29, 2011, 01:04:36 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 2
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 4 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 29, 2011, 03:30:32 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 1 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 4
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4 (+1)
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 29, 2011, 03:32:38 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4 (-1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 1
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 9
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 29, 2011, 03:37:21 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 4
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 0 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 7

Salamandastron has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 29, 2011, 04:10:34 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 29, 2011, 04:27:06 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 4 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on September 29, 2011, 05:51:14 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 5
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 4
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 3 (1-)
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 29, 2011, 07:02:24 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 5
Martin the Warrior 5
The Bellmaker 5
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 4
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 3
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 10
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Folgrimeo on September 29, 2011, 07:49:12 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6 (+1)
The Bellmaker 2 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 4
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 29, 2011, 09:08:18 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 3 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 29, 2011, 09:14:45 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 7 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 3
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 29, 2011, 09:17:27 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 7
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 2 (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 6 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 29, 2011, 09:21:53 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox 2
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 6
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 29, 2011, 11:28:04 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
Marlfox (-1)
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 7
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 7 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 29, 2011, 02:39:14 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 8 (+1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 7

I hope y'all know I eliminated Salamadastron and Marlfox a while ago. And you kept adding them back to the list. I took them off the list because they weren'n suppose to be there.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 29, 2011, 02:46:05 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 1 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on September 29, 2011, 02:47:12 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
The Bellmaker 0 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8

The Bellmaker has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 29, 2011, 03:14:17 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mattimeo 4 (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on September 29, 2011, 04:41:57 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Mattimeo 3 (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on September 29, 2011, 05:00:04 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mattimeo 2 (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on September 29, 2011, 07:08:34 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mattimeo (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on September 30, 2011, 06:40:55 AM
I think the above post should have Mattimeo as 1

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mattimeo 1
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 7
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on September 30, 2011, 10:09:46 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mattimeo 1
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 6 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 9 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 01, 2011, 02:46:39 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 6
Mattimeo 4 (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Salamandastron 4
Martin the Warrior 6
Bellmaker 2
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearles of lutra 5
The long Patrol 11 (+1)
Marlfox 4
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Ruhlain 4
Doomwyte 4
Sable Quean 7
The Rough Crew 5
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 01, 2011, 02:55:18 AM
Trisscar95, I believe you haven't quite got hang of the rules yet. Please read them on the first page.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mattimeo 1
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 5 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 01, 2011, 03:16:47 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mattimeo 0 (-1)
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 6
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 10

Mattimeo has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 01, 2011, 06:21:57 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 01, 2011, 07:33:52 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 5
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 01, 2011, 08:37:25 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 6 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 4
The Sable Quean 4 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 02, 2011, 03:35:46 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 6
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 6
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3 (-)
The Sable Quean 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 03, 2011, 02:50:55 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 7 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 6
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 03, 2011, 07:49:59 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 7
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 03, 2011, 02:48:23 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 7
Outcast of Redwall 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 03, 2011, 03:29:30 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 7
Outcast of Redwall 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 5
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 03, 2011, 03:30:20 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 7
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 03, 2011, 03:32:26 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 8 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 03, 2011, 03:33:30 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 03, 2011, 03:36:56 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 03, 2011, 03:42:11 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 04, 2011, 12:48:42 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 04, 2011, 02:47:10 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (+)
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 3
The Rogue Crew 10

I believe lily made a mistake with the numbers, this is what TLoL should look like
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 04, 2011, 04:50:08 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 04, 2011, 05:04:26 AM
Quote from: Captain Tammo on October 04, 2011, 02:47:10 AM
I believe lily made a mistake with the numbers, this is what TLoL should look like

Haha, I sure did, thanks Tammo!

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 8
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 2
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 04, 2011, 08:54:03 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 1 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 04, 2011, 02:11:10 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 2 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 2 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 04, 2011, 03:25:50 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 04, 2011, 09:40:02 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4 (+)
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 1
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 05, 2011, 04:06:11 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Sable Quean 0 (-1) eliminated
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 05, 2011, 04:33:51 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 05, 2011, 05:21:27 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 10 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 05, 2011, 05:30:48 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 2
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 05, 2011, 06:13:08 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 5
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 1 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 05, 2011, 04:02:51 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 6 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
Doomwyte 0 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10

Doomwyte has been eliminated!!!!!!  ;D ;D ;D (If you can't tell, I strongly disliked that book!)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 06, 2011, 12:41:55 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 4
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 06, 2011, 01:52:33 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 8 (+1)
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 06, 2011, 01:54:08 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 3 
Lord Brocktree 8
Taggerung 7 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 06, 2011, 01:54:44 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 2 (-1) 
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 06, 2011, 01:56:11 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 1 (-1) 
Lord Brocktree 9 
Taggerung 8 (+1)
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 06, 2011, 02:04:20 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 0 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 10 (+1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10

Legend of Luke is eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 06, 2011, 02:54:05 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (-1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 06, 2011, 04:45:01 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 3 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 06, 2011, 05:15:30 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 06, 2011, 07:12:11 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10 
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Tiria Wildlough on October 06, 2011, 11:56:07 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
Taggerung 7 (-1)
High Rhulain 3 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10 
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 06, 2011, 02:13:33 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 10 (+1)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 06, 2011, 04:23:47 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 06, 2011, 09:46:53 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 3 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Skalrag of Marshank on October 06, 2011, 11:08:32 PM
Redwall 8 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10 (-1)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 07, 2011, 11:47:00 AM
Lord Brocktree should be on 9 as Skalrag took 1 off it.

Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 3 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 07, 2011, 08:15:34 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 4 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Nightfire on October 07, 2011, 08:54:18 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 11 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 07, 2011, 10:44:03 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 11
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10 (+1)
Taggerung 6 (-1)
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10


down with the taggerung
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 07, 2011, 11:23:29 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 9 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 6
High Rhulain 5 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10

Whoa where'd long patrol go? I thought it had 10?
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 07, 2011, 11:56:02 PM
I'm not sure. You might look back to see whether it was actually eliminated or just accidently left out.

Redwall 9
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Taggerung 7 (+1)
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 08, 2011, 12:16:26 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 8 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10

It was left out
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 08, 2011, 12:43:28 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 11 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 08, 2011, 01:33:18 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 11
Taggerung 8 (+1)
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10

I thought the different books weren't supposed to get above 10  ???
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 08, 2011, 03:36:17 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 7 (-1)
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10

They're not, Triss made a mistake. I put it back on 10.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 08, 2011, 04:04:50 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 7 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 08, 2011, 07:04:37 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 08, 2011, 01:32:32 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 08, 2011, 03:56:13 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 8 (+1)
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 08, 2011, 04:00:20 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 4 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 08, 2011, 04:02:27 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 8
High Rhulain 5 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 08, 2011, 04:18:58 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 7 (-1)
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 08, 2011, 04:20:38 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 9 (-)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 08, 2011, 05:26:09 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 3 (-)
Pearls of lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 11(+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 5
The Rogue Crew 9
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 08, 2011, 06:15:54 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 3
Pearls of lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 11
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 6 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 8 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 08, 2011, 07:44:56 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 2 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 12 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 08, 2011, 08:13:23 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 3 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 12
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7 (-1)
   
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 09, 2011, 01:42:53 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 12
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 09, 2011, 02:23:26 AM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
Taggerung 7
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7

Just to clear things up, the rules state that book scores may not go above 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 09, 2011, 03:27:08 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 8 (+1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 09, 2011, 08:26:52 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 7 (-1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 09, 2011, 03:04:36 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 6 (-1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 09, 2011, 04:16:32 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 5 (-1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 8 (+1)

I can't decide on my favourite book! I'm leaning towards The Rogue Crew, though. Ooutcast had good characters, but a bit of a dull plot.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 09, 2011, 09:55:45 PM
Redwall 9(-1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 6(+1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 10, 2011, 05:19:12 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 5(-)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 10, 2011, 05:24:39 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 4 (-)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 10, 2011, 05:35:16 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 3 (-)
High Rhulain 6
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 10, 2011, 05:36:58 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 2 (-)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 9 (+1)

You forgot The Rogue Crew, Rakkety Tam.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 10, 2011, 05:52:40 AM
oh sorry my bad


Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung 1 (-)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)


u may have the honers of taking down taggerung daniel

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 10, 2011, 05:55:22 AM
Why thank you!



Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 7 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
Taggerung (-1)
High Rhulain 6
The Rogue Crew 10

Taggerung has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 10, 2011, 06:01:36 AM
no prob man plus i cant double post so i had to ;D


Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 5(-)
The Rogue Crew 10


man i disliked the taggerung alot thank goodness he is gone

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 10, 2011, 08:06:44 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 4 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 10, 2011, 08:51:51 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (-)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 5 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 10, 2011, 10:39:22 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6(-1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 4(+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 11, 2011, 01:03:43 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7(+1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 3(-1)
The Rogue Crew 10

i realy did not like high rhulain
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 11, 2011, 01:39:37 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 9 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 3
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Tiria Wildlough on October 11, 2011, 06:27:46 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
High Rhulain 4 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 11, 2011, 06:57:41 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 5 (-1)
The Long Patrol 9
High Rhulain 4
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 11, 2011, 07:57:59 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 5
The Long Patrol 10 (+1)
High Rhulain 3 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 11, 2011, 03:09:02 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 11, 2011, 04:03:35 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain 1 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 11, 2011, 08:18:04 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree8(+1)
The Long Patrol 10
High Rhulain (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 11, 2011, 08:51:16 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 12, 2011, 02:05:48 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of redwall 10
Outcast of redwall 9 (-)
Pearls of lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The long Patrol 11 (+)
The rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 12, 2011, 02:21:36 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of redwall 10
Outcast of redwall  10 (+1)
Pearls of lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The long Patrol 10
The rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 12, 2011, 04:45:13 AM
Trisscar, a book can't go over 10.


Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 12, 2011, 11:37:01 AM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 12, 2011, 03:15:34 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 12, 2011, 04:30:32 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 12, 2011, 04:31:59 PM
Both books I added to are gone. :( That's depressing...

Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 13, 2011, 05:24:59 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9 (+1)
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 9
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 13, 2011, 09:29:01 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 13, 2011, 10:16:27 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 13, 2011, 01:17:34 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (+1)
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 13, 2011, 03:41:52 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (+1)
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 13, 2011, 08:33:59 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 13, 2011, 10:27:22 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8 (-)
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 9
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 14, 2011, 11:35:14 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7 (-1)
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Folgrimeo on October 14, 2011, 06:42:04 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

I'm glad we're double-checking our work and re-iterating rules since not many people are reading the first page, but... we still had a casualty that wasn't noticed. "Martin the Warrior" got dropped on the 9th page early on, although it was at 10 votes.

I have to ask: how many people are Copy+Pasting the previous post (to help ensure mistakes aren't made), or just typing them out manually? Please, Copy+Paste instead.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 14, 2011, 08:07:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 9
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

I just quote the one before me and delete all of the extra stuff in it
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 15, 2011, 01:54:06 AM
Martin the Warrior got dropped? Can we put it back? I like that one!
BTW, I copy and paste as my insert quote button hasn't been working lately.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 7
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
Lord Brocktree 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 8 (-1)

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 15, 2011, 06:29:37 AM
I put Martin the Warrior back in. It disappeared after Skalrag missed it. Tammo was the last to have it in. I copy/paste, personally. Also, Icefire, you took 1 of The Rogue Crew when it was on 10, but you put it up as 8. It should have been 9. I added to it, and I made it 10.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 15, 2011, 05:50:45 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 8 (-)
Pearls of lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 11 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 16, 2011, 02:29:23 AM
Trisscar95, a book can't go above 10.


Redwall 10
Mossflower 9
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 16, 2011, 04:07:52 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 16, 2011, 10:25:23 PM
Oops! Sorry 'bout my last post! :-[

Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 8 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 17, 2011, 01:15:13 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 7 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 17, 2011, 03:28:31 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on October 17, 2011, 04:52:15 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 17, 2011, 06:05:13 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 17, 2011, 01:26:49 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 7
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 17, 2011, 05:53:04 PM
 Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 6 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 17, 2011, 09:40:19 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 6
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 17, 2011, 11:19:30 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 8 (+)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 18, 2011, 12:08:13 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 6 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 18, 2011, 01:37:56 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 18, 2011, 03:56:04 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 18, 2011, 10:08:24 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 7
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 18, 2011, 10:30:29 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5(+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6(-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 19, 2011, 05:28:50 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7
Martin the Warrior 10 (+)
Outcast of Redwall 4(-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 6
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 19, 2011, 08:12:50 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 5 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 19, 2011, 09:46:40 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 4 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 19, 2011, 01:11:52 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 3 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 19, 2011, 01:59:59 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 2 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 19, 2011, 02:02:47 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 1 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

We're soon gonna have to stop +1-ing, 'cause there won't be anything left to raise.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 19, 2011, 02:11:19 PM
Sure thing!

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 10
Lord Brocktree 0 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Lord Brocktree has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 19, 2011, 08:00:42 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 20, 2011, 01:07:47 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 5
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 20, 2011, 01:17:51 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10 (+)
Outcast of Redwall 4 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 20, 2011, 08:56:55 AM
Icefire, we aren't adding for a while, at the moment.


Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 20, 2011, 08:27:13 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3 (-)
Pearles of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (+)
The Rogue crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 20, 2011, 11:18:36 PM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3
Pearles of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 20, 2011, 11:29:53 PM
Redwall 8
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall4(+)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9(-)
The Rogue crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 21, 2011, 12:59:51 AM
Are we back to adding?


Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 21, 2011, 04:24:36 AM
Did you get that we weren't adding from the post where Matthias asked what we would do when they all reached 10? I didn't add, I simply showed what I would add to if it weren't already at 10

Redwall 9 
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10 (+)
Outcast of Redwall 3 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 21, 2011, 10:18:37 PM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 21, 2011, 10:19:29 PM

Must save Outcast

Redwall 9  
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4(+)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 7(-)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on October 21, 2011, 10:29:29 PM
Redwall 8  (-1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 4
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 22, 2011, 04:11:13 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 22, 2011, 07:09:47 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10 (+)
Outcast of Redwall 2 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 22, 2011, 07:36:38 PM
Redwall 8(-1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3(+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10

In my defense Outcast was a good book.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 22, 2011, 09:59:52 PM
Redwall 7 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 3
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 23, 2011, 12:51:33 AM
Redwall 7
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 2 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 23, 2011, 07:45:23 AM
Redwall 8 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 1 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 23, 2011, 02:00:14 PM
Redwall 7(-1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 2 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 23, 2011, 02:52:43 PM
Why are you guys dissing Redwall?

Redwall 8 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 1 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 23, 2011, 03:13:30 PM
I'm not...

Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Outcast of Redwall 0 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Outcast of Redwall has been eliminated. It had good characters (Skarlath, Sunflash), I just thought it was a tad boring.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 23, 2011, 03:20:49 PM
And I thank you for that. (And I agree with you that is was a bit bland.)

Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 23, 2011, 03:27:50 PM
Oh great... I guess we'll have to only take again, otherwise it will be a continual cycle, as you will have to add to the one with 9.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 23, 2011, 04:13:14 PM
Or we could reduce everything by 5. Just a thought.
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on October 23, 2011, 04:45:28 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9(-1)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 24, 2011, 01:03:28 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 8(-1)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on October 24, 2011, 08:23:48 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 24, 2011, 09:10:14 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10

That would be a good idea, Matthias.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 24, 2011, 01:45:48 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Gonff on October 24, 2011, 03:12:16 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10 (+)
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 24, 2011, 04:08:24 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 24, 2011, 10:21:37 PM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 9

Down with redwall!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: winifred on October 25, 2011, 01:44:52 AM
Quote from: Captain Tammo on October 24, 2011, 10:21:37 PM


Down with redwall!!!
redwall 9(1+)
mossflower 10
mariel of redwall 9
martin the warrior 9
pearls of lutra 10
the long patrol 10
the rogue crew 8(1-)

why down with redwall?
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 25, 2011, 08:41:17 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 9
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 9 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 25, 2011, 02:27:03 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 8 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 25, 2011, 03:00:20 PM
Ummm... Matthias? I think you made a few mistakes there...
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 25, 2011, 04:50:32 PM
So technically, this is where it should be, right?

Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+)
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 8 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 25, 2011, 06:34:38 PM
Wait, what?

... ><

Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 25, 2011, 11:14:10 PM
Redwall 9 -
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 +
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on October 26, 2011, 06:25:03 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 6 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 26, 2011, 01:05:59 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 7 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 26, 2011, 01:16:37 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 7
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 26, 2011, 01:18:16 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 26, 2011, 10:51:04 PM
Redwall 9 -
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10 +
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 27, 2011, 02:36:51 AM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 8
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 27, 2011, 09:41:14 AM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 9 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 27, 2011, 01:23:21 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 7 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)

Transposition error. ><
I reaaly shouldn't play this game while distracted.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 27, 2011, 02:19:08 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5 (-)
Martin the warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 8 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 27, 2011, 02:35:53 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5
Martin the Warrior 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on October 27, 2011, 03:31:37 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 8
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 27, 2011, 10:45:48 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 3 -
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 9 +
The Rogue Crew 10

Thanks trisscar95!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 28, 2011, 08:39:43 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4 +
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 -
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10


no my second fav book i need some help plz

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 29, 2011, 04:38:37 AM
Redwall 9 -
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5 +
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10

Ok I'll help you out buddy ;D  ,as long as you help me get rid of redwall
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on October 29, 2011, 11:53:29 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4(-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 30, 2011, 01:30:39 PM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5(+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

ok i'll help redwall isnt one of my favs so i'm fine with it persionaly it wasnt the best book but BJ didnt have much expeariance then probably
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on October 30, 2011, 07:13:05 PM
Redwall 7 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6(+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 31, 2011, 01:28:43 AM
Redwall 6 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7(+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on October 31, 2011, 09:05:08 AM
Redwall 7 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Umm... Without Redwall, we wouldn't have any of the other books... Plus it is awesome!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on October 31, 2011, 01:56:16 PM
Redwall 6 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7(+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

yeah its a good book but its definitly not my fav
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 01, 2011, 09:29:08 PM
Redwall 5 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 8(+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

I agree, they're all incredible but it's not my favorite
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 02, 2011, 09:14:54 AM
Redwall 6 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 7 (-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 02, 2011, 12:46:03 PM
Redwall 7 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 6 (-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 02, 2011, 01:21:01 PM
Redwall 8 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5 (-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 02, 2011, 01:51:53 PM
Redwall 9 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4 (-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 02, 2011, 02:49:19 PM
Redwall 8 (-)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5 (+)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

come on i need some help
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 02, 2011, 03:03:44 PM
Come on. Show love to the first book.
Redwall 9 (+)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4 (-)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 02, 2011, 08:30:57 PM
Redwall 8 -
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 5 +
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Sorry about that Tam! Had school. Anyway,
EULALIA!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 02, 2011, 11:29:36 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 4 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 03, 2011, 12:02:13 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 3 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 03, 2011, 01:26:12 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 2 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 03, 2011, 09:15:41 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 1 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Oh, great, looks like we might not be able to add again...
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 03, 2011, 12:39:44 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Mariel of Redwall 0 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

And Mariel of Redwall was eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 03, 2011, 01:09:11 PM
Hurrah!

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 03, 2011, 02:21:01 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

noooooooooooo its my fault i wasnt on i will everything possible to get rid of redwall
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on November 03, 2011, 02:26:58 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 03, 2011, 11:08:01 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 04, 2011, 07:23:23 PM
Redwall 8 -
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10 +
The Rogue Crew 10

I'm sorry tam! DOWN WITH REDWALL!!!!! Never thought I'd say that! Hahah
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 04, 2011, 09:25:41 PM
Redwall 7 -
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10

it wasnt your fault mate it was mine and i never thought i would say that either doooowwwwn with reeeddddwaaaalllll
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 05, 2011, 12:28:03 AM
Redwall 6 -
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 05, 2011, 04:41:37 AM
Redwall 6
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 05, 2011, 06:29:37 PM
Redwall 5 -
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 06, 2011, 07:36:29 AM
I think we can add now...

Redwall 6 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 06, 2011, 05:39:40 PM

Redwall 5 -
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10 +
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 06, 2011, 05:56:33 PM
Redwall 6 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 6 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 06, 2011, 06:59:59 PM
Redwall 5 (-1)
Mossflower10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Cheesethief on November 06, 2011, 07:55:48 PM
Redwall 4 (-1)
Mossflower10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 06, 2011, 11:52:44 PM
Redwall 5 (+1)
Mossflower10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (-1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Plugg Firetail on November 07, 2011, 12:59:24 AM
Redwall 6(+1)
Mossflower 9(-1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 07, 2011, 01:37:41 AM
Redwall 5 -
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8 +
The Long Patrol 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 07, 2011, 02:04:56 AM
Redwall 6 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 07, 2011, 11:58:42 AM
Redwall 7 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 8 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 07, 2011, 12:14:40 PM
Redwall 8 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 7 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 07, 2011, 12:45:17 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 6 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 07, 2011, 03:02:31 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 5 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 07, 2011, 10:09:05 PM
Redwall 9 -
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 6 +
The Rogue Crew 10

Gasp! What is this!? Haha
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 08, 2011, 01:31:57 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 6 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 08, 2011, 02:05:31 AM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 7 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10

i'm here for yah tammo
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 08, 2011, 03:48:33 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 6 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 08, 2011, 06:05:02 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 5 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 08, 2011, 07:48:05 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 4 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 08, 2011, 09:13:12 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Long Patrol 3 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 08, 2011, 01:09:50 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 2 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 08, 2011, 01:20:27 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 1 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 08, 2011, 01:37:36 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Long Patrol 0 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10

And thus The Long Patrol was removed from play...
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Rakefur on November 08, 2011, 01:39:49 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 9
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 08, 2011, 10:44:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 8 -
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10

LUTRAAAAAA!!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 09, 2011, 12:57:12 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 8
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 09, 2011, 03:17:59 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 7 -
Pearls of Lutra 10 +
The Rogue Crew 10

LUTRAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!
I can't help but feel that for every book I vote for, there's 3 that want it gone more than any other book! (of course I'm not really mad)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 09, 2011, 05:00:14 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 8 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 09, 2011, 01:05:17 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Martin the Warrior 8
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Cheesethief on November 09, 2011, 08:02:54 PM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 09, 2011, 08:08:37 PM
Redwall 9
Mossflower 9 -
Martin the Warrior 8
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 10, 2011, 07:47:37 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 9
Martin the Warrior 8
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 10, 2011, 02:06:06 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Martin the Warrior 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 10, 2011, 10:42:34 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 6 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10 +
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 11, 2011, 07:59:00 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 7 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on November 11, 2011, 03:40:03 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 8 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 11, 2011, 04:21:43 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 9
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 11, 2011, 04:36:35 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 6 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 9
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 12, 2011, 05:13:34 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 6
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 12, 2011, 03:19:35 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 5 -
Pearls of Lutra 10 +
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on November 12, 2011, 07:31:49 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 11 (+)
Martin the warrior 4 (-)
Pearls of lutra 10
The Rogue crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 13, 2011, 05:19:07 AM
Trisscar95, you've been told before that a book can't go above 10.


Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 5 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 13, 2011, 03:54:06 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 4 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10

Sorry Daniel, but I must disagree with you on these number changes.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 13, 2011, 06:26:13 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 3 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 13, 2011, 06:33:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 2 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 13, 2011, 07:09:59 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 3 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 13, 2011, 11:39:00 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 2 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 14, 2011, 01:19:33 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 1 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 14, 2011, 01:36:39 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Martin the Warrior 0 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 10

Martin the Warrior has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 14, 2011, 09:09:14 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 14, 2011, 08:03:01 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 15, 2011, 12:14:01 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 15, 2011, 12:25:05 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 8 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 15, 2011, 12:35:09 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 15, 2011, 01:54:19 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 6 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on November 15, 2011, 05:23:09 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+)
The Rogue Crew 5 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 15, 2011, 06:01:13 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 4 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 15, 2011, 07:50:09 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 5 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 15, 2011, 11:34:36 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 4 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 15, 2011, 12:31:23 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 5 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on November 15, 2011, 03:18:46 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 4 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on November 15, 2011, 04:06:31 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 3 (-1)
   
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 15, 2011, 05:31:56 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10
The Rogue Crew 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Taggerung_of_Redwall on November 15, 2011, 05:33:41 PM
I haven't read the Rogue Crew, so I'll leave that out.
I find myself only playing this game when its down to a few.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
The Rogue Crew 2

I love Redwall and Mossflower, so I guess that seals Pearls of Lutra for getting the negative
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on November 15, 2011, 05:35:36 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 15, 2011, 06:01:26 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
The Rogue Crew 0 (-1)

The Rouge Crew has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 15, 2011, 09:33:53 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 -
Pearls of Lutra 10 +
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Flandor on November 15, 2011, 09:40:15 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 10 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 16, 2011, 01:42:43 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 -
Pearls of Lutra 10 +
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 16, 2011, 07:46:58 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 17, 2011, 02:15:17 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 17, 2011, 07:35:33 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 17, 2011, 12:29:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 8 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 17, 2011, 12:58:42 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 17, 2011, 01:56:04 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 6 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on November 17, 2011, 03:43:57 PM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 7 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on November 17, 2011, 05:03:39 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 6 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 17, 2011, 05:41:50 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 5 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on November 17, 2011, 06:23:10 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 4 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 17, 2011, 07:59:32 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 5 (+)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 18, 2011, 02:46:31 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 4 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on November 18, 2011, 02:49:18 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 3 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 18, 2011, 08:58:55 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 18, 2011, 11:05:07 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 3 (+)

LUTRAAAAAAAAA!!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 18, 2011, 01:24:26 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 18, 2011, 05:08:48 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 3 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Redwall Musician on November 18, 2011, 06:48:27 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 18, 2011, 07:58:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 3 (+1)

Somebeast help!
LUTRAAAAAA!!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 19, 2011, 07:12:38 AM
Wait a minute, if Matthias took away from Pearls of Lutra, why did he add to its total?


Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 19, 2011, 01:55:51 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 3 (+1)

I saw that too, I just thought he forgot to change the sign or something.

LUTRAAAAAA!!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on November 19, 2011, 09:35:11 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Massflower 10 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 3
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 20, 2011, 02:39:49 AM
Redwall 8 (-)
Massflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 4 (+)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 20, 2011, 06:15:57 AM
What's Massflower?  ;)


Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 3 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 20, 2011, 11:05:24 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 20, 2011, 11:22:20 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 20, 2011, 04:10:15 PM
Redwall 9 (-)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 20, 2011, 04:21:40 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 20, 2011, 05:48:50 PM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (+1)

I HAVE AN IDEA!!! Don't take off of Pearls of Lutra ;D
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 20, 2011, 06:18:06 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)

Ummm... No.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 20, 2011, 06:25:18 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-)
Pearls of Lutra 2 (+1)

I dunnoooo, Mossflower seems to be a big threat to redwall and vice verca. Look at Pearls of Lutra! I've got 2, not much a threat is it?
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 20, 2011, 07:08:24 PM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 21, 2011, 12:33:40 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 2 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 21, 2011, 01:09:21 AM
Redwall 10
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 21, 2011, 02:23:20 AM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 2 (+1)

Somebeast please help for Holt Lutra's sake!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 21, 2011, 05:39:22 AM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 1 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 21, 2011, 07:56:16 AM
Sorry, Tammo.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 0 (-1)

Pearls of Lutra has been eliminated.
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 21, 2011, 11:38:32 AM
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 21, 2011, 11:53:33 AM
Please don't strectch the screen, Tammo, even if you are upset.

Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Icefire on November 21, 2011, 03:34:35 PM
Quote from: DanielofRedwall on November 21, 2011, 07:56:16 AM
Sorry, Tammo.

Redwall 10
Mossflower 10
Pearls of Lutra 0 (-1)

Pearls of Lutra has been eliminated.
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!  :'( I've been gone too long.

Redwall 8
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 21, 2011, 04:19:23 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Trisscar95 on November 21, 2011, 04:58:38 PM
Redwall 8(-)
Mossflower 10(+)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 21, 2011, 05:34:14 PM
Redwall 9 (+1)
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 21, 2011, 07:53:26 PM
Quote from: DanielofRedwall on November 21, 2011, 11:53:33 AM
Please don't strectch the screen, Tammo, even if you are upset.

O wow I didn't realize that till you said it! My bad

Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 8 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on November 21, 2011, 08:24:38 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 21, 2011, 08:28:54 PM
Redwall 10 (+1)
Mossflower 6 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 22, 2011, 12:31:25 AM
Redwall 9 (-1)
Mossflower 7 (+1)


sorry tammo but i realy think  redwall wasnt a good book well at leats compared to the other ones
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 12:53:31 AM
Redwall 8 (-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 12:55:13 AM
Quote from: rakkety tam on November 22, 2011, 12:31:25 AM
sorry tammo but i realy think  redwall wasnt a good book well at leats compared to the other ones

No worries I hear ye, it's the last 2 books, and neither are my favorite (pearls of Lutra and long patrol got eliminated) so I'm just voting for the one that wasn't in the finals last time.

Redwall 9(+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 22, 2011, 12:57:11 AM
Redwall 8(-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)

ok cool long patrol was one of my favs to
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 12:59:03 AM
Redwall 9(+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 01:09:05 AM
Redwall 8 (-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 01:11:41 AM
Redwall 9(+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 01:21:16 AM
Redwall 8 (-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 01:30:42 AM
Redwall 9(+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Mad Maudie on November 22, 2011, 02:56:00 AM
Redwall 8 (-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 02:57:17 AM
Redwall 9(+1)
Mossflower 7 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 04:36:00 AM
Redwall 8 (-1)
Mossflower 8 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 22, 2011, 07:56:29 AM
Redwall 7 (-1)
Mossflower 9 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Tiria Wildlough on November 22, 2011, 08:32:45 AM
Redwall 6 (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)


Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 09:46:55 AM
Redwall 5 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 22, 2011, 10:51:13 AM
Redwall 4 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 11:11:58 AM
Redwall 3 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 22, 2011, 01:41:14 PM
Redwall 4 (+1)
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 22, 2011, 02:07:06 PM
Redwall (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 22, 2011, 02:15:20 PM
Redwall 4 (+1)
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Lily on November 22, 2011, 02:19:09 PM
Redwall 3 (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 22, 2011, 04:10:47 PM
Redwall 4 (+1)
Mossflower 9 (-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: rakkety tam on November 22, 2011, 08:24:41 PM
Redwall 3 (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)



whooooooooooooooo
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Captain Tammo on November 22, 2011, 10:08:46 PM
Redwall 4 (+1)
Mossflower 9(-1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 23, 2011, 08:23:47 AM
Redwall 3 (-1)
Mossflower 10 (+1)
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Tiria Wildlough on November 23, 2011, 08:24:53 AM
Redwall 2 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: DanielofRedwall on November 23, 2011, 10:19:04 AM
Redwall 1 (-1)
Mossflower 10
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Tiria Wildlough on November 23, 2011, 10:22:06 AM
Redwall 0 (-1)
Mossflower 10

Redwall has been eliminated. Mossflower has won the competition. ;D
Title: Re: Redwall Book Elimination #2!
Post by: Matthias720 on November 23, 2011, 02:34:08 PM
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!

*sigh*

On to round #3.
Text only | Text with Images