Eulalia! -The Book, and Me Wondering why Everybeast Hates It

[Ashleg]

Why're you named after Mask if Maudie's your favorite, eh?

Honestly I didn't like her much, but that's my opinion.

[Ungatt Trunn]

It has been a pretty long while since I read it, but I don't remember having any grievances with it... I remember that the battle scenes were pretty kool.

The only Redwall book that I remember having a distinct negative opinion about was Marlfox... I remember I got into some pretty heated arguments about my dislike for it on the old forum 

[Ashleg]

Ahuh, Marlfox blended in to the rest--had it not been Raventail I would be indifferent on it.
Well, so did this book.

[Ripred the Gnawer]

About the title of this topic:
I love Eulalia.

[clunylooney]

I personally think that Eulalia! is the most OK book ever created. There are some good, some bad, and then almost all of it is OK. I liked the villain, and the main character (forgot his name) and his little buddy were alright. I liked the hare I think. The plateau was cool. the side villains were fun. The Guosim were pretty good in this book. It was mainly the actual plot and adventure that were dull. But I do like Vizka, the fat rat guy, and both of their crews. And like I said, the main guy and Orkwill are pretty good.