do u think bj should have put dogs in redwall

[Ciaran Galedeep]

i think there would be a good chance that a dog would fall into the fickle category of the few large creatures we've seen throughout the series like the Squire Julian (a decedent of a wildcat) the walruses that appeared in PoL and TLoL, the two golden eagles, Aurgulo and Wild King Mcphearsome, the swans in Mossflower and The Legend of Luke, the Crow Breathern Snake Fish, the Deepcoiler, Yo Karr, the few Sharks that have appeared and any other large creatures. they are dangerous to both friend and foe and act on whimsical tastes or ferocious instincts. 

[Bluefire]

I think a dog in just one or two books would be interesting. Huge animals are usually only mentioned in 1 book.

[Redwaller]

false

There's a shark in the BellMaker

[Ungatt Trunn]

I think that it would depend if they were on the good side or the evil side (I think that if there were dogs in Redwall, they should of been evil).

[Redwallfan7]

I think dogs on the good side and on the evil side would have been good. For the good side, these breeds come to mind: yorkies, Jack Russels, Dalmatians

bad side breeds: Rottweilers, some larger breeds

[gorath]

I don't like dogs. They would probably kill enemies by slobbering

[Redwallfan7]

There are some dog breeds that don't constantly slobber, you know. Are you more of a cat person?