Any good ideas

[Log a Log Grenn]

Have you ever come up with an idea for a book?

[Mariel]

I don't think I could ever come up with an idea for an entire book.  However, I have written a few "alternate" versions of instances in which characters make different decisions, etc.

I've also always wondered what would happen if humans discovered
Redwall, or something equally surreal.  But obviously this could never happen; it would be like going to a funeral on Christmas.

[Log a Log Grenn]

I'd hate it if humans came
I came up with one about Samkim and Arula ( Salamandastron)
When they have to go on a journey to kill Martin the Warrior's evil rat cousin Zlang the Undefeated
But then they get trapped in a cave with 7 snakes and they find Tim Churchmouse whose been poisoned

It's a very bad story but it was all I could think of
and I didn't write it I just thought it

[Mariel]

I'd hate it if humans came
I came up with one about Samkim and Arula ( Salamandastron)
When they have to go on a journey to kill Martin the Warrior's evil rat cousin Zlang the Undefeated
But then they get trapped in a cave with 7 snakes and they find Tim Churchmouse whose been poisoned

It's a very bad story but it was all I could think of
and I didn't write it I just thought it

Cool!  I think it's funny at the very least.  You should write it!

[The Lady Shael]

If you do end up writing it, you should post it on the Redwall Fanfiction Board.

The only story that I ever really worked on was called "If Rose Had Lived". It's around somewhere, unfinished.

An idea I had for a book was called "The Missing Saga", because I really really really wanted to know what happened between the books Salamandastron, and Redwall. I don't think we really know how many seasons time passed between those two books, it could've been one generation, or 20 generations.

[edit] Sorry, Salamandastron, not Outcast of Redwall, wow it's been a while.

[Log a Log Grenn]

I'll start writing it if people would like to read it
Nice idea Lady S
I was always confused between what happened  during the books

[daskar666]

My idea:Legend of Luke rewritten.
I'm actually working on a book length fanfiction of a rewritten version.
Synopsis: In the prologue, Vilu Daskar (a very young pirate) invades Luke's village and gets away with it.
In the first book, Vilu, now older, is now a pirate king (except he operates from the Goreleech, not Terramort/Sampetra) and uses sharks that are in his service to send bottled messages to other pirate ships which serve him. He sends some of his vermin to conquer Redwall. Martin goes on a quest after them while the Redwallers struggle to defeat the vermin offensive against the unfinished abbey. At the end of book 1 Martin discovers that shortly after departure from his caves, Luke became Vilu's prisoner and is still a prisoner on the Goreleech.
In book 2, Luke escapes and goes off on his own quest while Martin continues on his. At the end of book 2 they meet. In book 3 they work together to defeat Daskar.
This way it's all one story instead of 2 separate stories.

[Log a Log Grenn]

Good idea
Still prefer the original thought

[martins#1fan]

I have an Idea, I think possibly, that martin has a son who of course, inherits the Legendary Sword of Luke the Warrior.
That's just an idea.

[Log a Log Grenn]

Good again

[martins#1fan]

Of course, his son's name I wouldn't choose but, possibly another M name, like:
Martin Jr.
Mark
Manny
Something like that.

[Log a Log Grenn]

How about Mathimius

[Matthias720]

How about Mathimius

o_O

[Log a Log Grenn]

What does o_O mean

[Matthias720]

Let me Google that for you