Redwall Elimination #3

[Icefire]

Mattimeo 4 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 9 (-1)
The Bellmaker 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 3

tammo what book should we add to or just me
[/quote]

[DanielofRedwall]

Mattimeo 4
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 9
The Bellmaker 9 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 4 (+1)

I don't know if it is just me, but I don't like the idea of teaming up. It turns the game from "add to and take from the book you like and dislike the most" (which is what it is meant to be) in to "add to and take from the book your friend wants you to, because he helped you take another book down". Also, it isn't fair if you really like a book, but because one other person doesn't, two people are taking from it (like me now with The Rogue Crew). That makes it two against one. It makes it more of a battle, not a game. So, guys, just think about that.

[Tiria Wildlough]

I don't care what happens as long as no one behaves badly. I don't need to team up with anyone. I will work at taking down a book until that book is down. So just think about that.

Mattimeo 4
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 9
The Bellmaker 9
Pearls of Lutra 8 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 4

It turns the game from "add to and take from the book you like and dislike the most" (which is what it is meant to be) in to "add to and take from the book your friend wants you to, because he helped you take another book down".

That's called helping a friend.

[Coobreedan]

Mattimeo 5 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8 (-1)
The Bellmaker 9
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6  
The Rogue Crew 4

I'm protecting the ones I like that are gonna be wiped out. If it's one I like that's fairly high, there's really no point in saving it.

[DanielofRedwall]

I did ask if it was just me...

Mattimeo 5
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 8 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6  
The Rogue Crew 5 (+1)

[Coobreedan]

Mattimeo 6 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 8
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 9 (-1)
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6   
The Rogue Crew 5

[Icefire]

I'm not teaming up. I just forgot to erase that message when I qouted the post before me.

Mattimeo 7 (+1)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 7 (-1)
The Bellmaker 8
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6   
The Rogue Crew 5

[rakkety tam]

Mattimeo 6 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8 (+)
The Bellmaker 8
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6   
The Rogue Crew 5

[Captain Tammo]

Mattimeo 2 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 10
The Bellmaker 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 7
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 3

I'm not going to add to any, all my favs are high enough up

tammo what book should we add to or just me
[/quote]

[rakkety tam]

Mattimeo 1 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 10
The Bellmaker 10
Pearls of Lutra 7
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 10
Lord Brocktree 10
Rakkety Tam 8 (+)
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 3

[DanielofRedwall]

How did Mattimeo go from 6 to 2 in one post? I'll correct that. Also, The Rogue Crew went from 5 to 3, and Salamandastron and The Bellmaker from 8 to 10. The Pearls of Lutra went from 8 to 7 and The Legend of Luke and Lord Brocktree from 9 to 10. You must have quoted the wrong post, Tammo.


Mattimeo 4
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 7 (-1)
Pearls of Lutra 8
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 8
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 6 (+1)

[Tiria Wildlough]

Mattimeo 4
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 7
Pearls of Lutra 9 (+1)
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8 (-1)
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 8
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 6

[rakkety tam]

Mattimeo 3 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 8 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 8
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 8
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 6

[Captain Tammo]

How did Mattimeo go from 6 to 2 in one post? I'll correct that. Also, The Rogue Crew went from 5 to 3, and Salamandastron and The Bellmaker from 8 to 10. The Pearls of Lutra went from 8 to 7 and The Legend of Luke and Lord Brocktree from 9 to 10. You must have quoted the wrong post, Tammo.

Whoa I did! My bad guys! Thanks for pointing that out daniel!

Mattimeo 2 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 8
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9 (+)
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 8
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 6

[rakkety tam]

Mattimeo 1 (-)
Mariel of Redwall 10
Salamandastron 8
The Bellmaker 9 (+)
Pearls of Lutra 9
The Long Patrol 10
The Legend of Luke 9
Lord Brocktree 9
Rakkety Tam 8
High Rhulain 10
The Sable Quean 6 
The Rogue Crew 6