Scout camp

[Booklover]

In which case,

Very, Ebby, not well. *shakes head in dismay* On that note, surely something is either killed or not killed, there's nothing in between (Schrödinger's cat doesn't count), so it would be 'It tastes killed.' Also, being killed won't make it taste different to being dead of natural causes, or not enough that a human (or whatever animal you may be) could taste the difference, making it 'It tastes dead.'

This still applies.

[Ebantu the Kararehe]

In the real world, maybe. But, as Verdauga said, this is the cellars.

[Booklover]

I removed the last sentence from the first post.

[Ebantu the Kararehe]

I noticed.

I was trying to be nice to Kade. He put a lot of effort in to killing those marshmellows; I was being polite.

[Kade Rivok]

Very, Ebby, not well. *shakes head in dismay* On that note, surely something is either killed or not killed, there's nothing in between (Schrödinger's cat doesn't count), so it would be 'It tastes killed.' Also, being killed won't make it taste different to being dead of natural causes, or not enough that a human (or whatever animal you may be) could taste the difference, making it 'It tastes dead.' Finally, we're talking about a marshmallow, which is not, as far as current evidence suggests, ever living (although some parts can come from animals), so it couldn't really be called dead.

Not sure if I need to actually break this down, but I guess I'm going to.

This is a rebuttal for your first two points.  She used "well" instead of "very" because she was going for the feeling of phrases like "well cooked" or "well done".  If someone handed you your favorite cooked food, and you ate it and liked it a lot, would you say "This was well cooked," or "This was very cooked"?

This is a rebuttal to your last two points.  She said this in the first place as a reference to the fact that I was hunting marshmallows.  Now, of course that isn't something one normally hunts, but I chose to do so because I thought it would be funny, and it was.  As I successfully hunted the marshmallow that I had given to Eb, her comment was structured around the fact that hunting marshmallows is a ridiculous concept to begin with and so she decided to play with that idea some more.  Something she did a very good job of.

In short... *A horde of marshmallows descend from the sky and attacks Booklover.*

[Ebantu the Kararehe]

Thanks Kade. That's what I was trying to say. *begins killing the marshmellow horde with teeth, claws, and arrows* (the arrows are used like kebabs, so we can feast after the fight.)

[shisteer of nothing much]

Blah, blah, blah. Finally, we're talking about a marshmallow, which is not, as far as current evidence suggests, ever living (although some parts can come from animals), so it couldn't really be called dead.

I disagree. Marshmallows originally were made out of plants, which have life and can, in fact, die. Also, marshmallows are one unit; they don't have separate parts, so either the whole marshmallow comes from an animal (or plant) or none of it does.

[Booklover]

Well then, who wants to hunt jelly babies with me?

[Ebantu the Kararehe]

Me! Me! *prepares hunting equipment*

[shisteer of nothing much]

I'll come. *grabs bow and arrows*

[lass of something much]

Well then, who wants to hunt jelly babies with me?

please bring me back some jelly cucumbers to?

*gives Ebby coconut sugar* Can I have some fresh fruit, oats and water, please, Lass?

shore-thing*hands Teer that    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^*

[shisteer of nothing much]

Thanks, Lass. *quickly eats breakfast, then follows Booklover and Ebby on their hunt*

[Booklover]

*passes some blue cookies to Ebby and Teer*

[Verdauga]

*Grabs cleaver and walks back to camp.*

[One-Eye the wildcat]

Thanks, Lass. *quickly eats breakfast, then follows Booklover and Ebby on their hunt*

*jumps up, gun in paw*

I'm coming too!