Saddest Redwall Book

[Tiria Wildlough]

MTW was not sad except for at the end, which failed to move me to tears (but then, almost nothing in writing can do that) . I would say that The Legend of Luke is really sad. Luke's death was predictable, but I feel cheated whenever I read that, and sad for Martin, because he never saw his father again.

[Martin the warrior]

The Legend of Luke was so sad    I remember going to my room and crying for Martin.

[Icefire]

Martin the Warrior moved me to tears......and I almost NEVER cry! That was years ago and I haven't cried over a book since.....although I almost wanted to last time I reread MTW.

[Trisscar95]

Triss, This book really made me cry when Drufo dies and then at the end of the book when Shog dies.
the other one I really cried on was The Long Patrol, when Russa Nodrey dies.

[brocka]

For me it was the death of Felldoh. I may have acted the same way if I had been born a slave. Sad waste of many lives.

[Driffle]

Martin the warrion when Rose of Noonvale dies

[Marlfox70]

Pearls of Lutra also sprang to my mind when I first read this topic. I remember being absolutely devastated when Piknim died. There was a moment like that in every book, I guess, but Piknim's death stands out for some reason.

I was depressed the rest of the day when that happened I wanted to find something to pay respects to her

Felldoh and Rose in Martin the Warrior also got me =[

Even in The Sable Quean I felt sad when Gliv wasn't able to avenge her mate. It's not often vermin show much remorse or emotion in these books so I was really hoping she'd get her chance.

When Skor's son in the rogue crew died that probably woulda been sadder for me if I wasn't so angry at how he died. >.> It didn't make any sense for that fox from the hinterlands Ketral Vayne to have gone there by himself even though he had an army of his own and then take a shot at just killing one person and trying to run. @_@

I really wanna read these all over again now I realize I forgot some moments in it's history. O_O Gotta finish the song of ice and fire series first though ;o

[Captain Tammo]

Loamhedge and Martin the warrior!

[Ceteruler]

Loamhedge and Martin the warrior!

Ditto and Triss

[Rollo the Baby Bankvole]

Now I've changed my mind after reading some of the other books...I would have to say Triss is one of the saddest because of how the slaves are treated so unfairly and because of poor Drufo and Shogg . Pearls of Lutra because of the Lutra Holt being killed for six pearls and of course Piknim . Oh, and The Taggerung because of Deyna growing up not knowing his real family and because of  Rillflag .

[Tiria Wildlough]

Now I've changed my mind after reading some of the other books...I would have to say Triss is one of the saddest because of how the slaves are treated so unfairly and because of poor Drufo and Shogg . Pearls of Lutra because of the Lutra Holt being killed for six pearls and of course Piknim . Oh, and The Taggerung because of Deyna growing up not knowing his real family and because of  Rillflag .

DON'T YOU DARE FORGET CREGGA!

[Rollo the Baby Bankvole]

Oh yeah, and Cregga, it was sad when she died, at least she was happy and it was a peaceful death, surrounded by her friend Mhera

[Tiria Wildlough]

Yeah, and that was more than Rillflag got.

[Skarlath]

I can't believe nobody's mentioned Skarlath! His death was always the saddest death for me.

[Melody]

I think loamhedge and martin the warrior are the saddest.