Saddest Redwall Book

[Dannflower Reguba]

Deynas' awesomer!  (This is off-topic)

[Tiria Wildlough]

I don't think Deyna's awesome. Also, we're off topic.

Saddest Redwall book, everyone?

[Capn Greypatch]

Well, like I said before, Outcast has gotta be one of the saddest...Skalrlath and Veil's death...very sad!

[W0NWILL]

The only Redwall book that moves me to tears every time I read it is Loamhedge, I didn't even cry at Rose's death. Maybe a little bit. I won't say who died in Loamhedge for fear of spoiling it. I think everyone knows that Rose dies.

[Tiria Wildlough]

The only time I had tears in my eyes was the part in Bellmaker where Blaggut returns Mother Mellus's badger cup. That part was so sad.

[Felldoh154]

Basically all of them are sad (all I can think of at least one main character dies) the saddest for me is Luke the warrior and Martin the warrior

[MatthiasMan]

Luke The Warrior and Martin the W. Obviously.

[Tiria Wildlough]

That part in The Legend of Luke where the Goreleech crashes is sad too. You can only imagine how Martin felt.

[Felldoh154]

Mr. J is good at making me love his characters than killing them and making me sad he does it in nearly every book

[W0NWILL]

That part in The Legend of Luke where the Goreleech crashes is sad too. You can only imagine how Martin felt.

The Legend of Luke is sad as well, second only to Loamhedge.
I wrote a fanfiction where Luke survives the Goreleech. It's called The Warrior Lives On.

[General Ironbeak]

.

Mattimeo... It is also a constantly sad novel, with the rescuers always getting so close to the stolen children, but then losing it.

Eh, I didn't find that sad. I mean, you've still got so much of a book left, you expect them to be rescued right then? Plus, it's so much more epic ending the story at the destination of the underground.

I know, I'm just looking at it like it's a story. I'm sorry.

. Also, just the storyline is a bit depressing, with children being stolen as revenge. And then there is the part where Queen Warbeak and Log-a-Log dies...

Those were seperate instances, though. Warbeak's effected me far more, since she was always a favorite of mine...

[Delthion]

The saddest one for m was Pearls of Lutra, I don't even know why, but it depressed me for several days afterwards.

[Rosey]

Martin the Warrior was very sad because both Rose of Noonvale and Feldoah die.........

[Hickory]

I pretty much never even got wet eyes in any book. So what? Call me heartless.

[Lady Ashenwyte]

Pearls of Lutra hands down. The storyline itself is depressing, with so many dying justfor six pink pearls for a pine marten.  This is an episode that has repeated itself many times in history, and that is why I'll always think The Pearls Of Lutra was one of the best books in the series.