Martin the Warrior Vs. Boar the Fighter

[Superdreuzel]

So, who do you guys think will win this fight?

[Melody]

I like Martin, boar was cool too and taught Martin some sword skills so I'm in the middle.

[Tiria Wildlough]

Boar was bigger and stronger, so he would have won.

[Taggerung_of_Redwall]

Keep in mind Martin and Boar did duel in Mossflower, and Boar easily disarmed the mouse warrior and spent a large portion of the day training him with the use of his newly forged sword.
As such, I'd go with Boar the Fighter.

[DanielofRedwall]

Boar, no question. Bigger, stronger and he taught Martin all he knew. Really, he was a better warrior than Martin at he time of his death. If Martin took on thousands of searats, even if hehad bloodwrath, i think he wouldn't survive nearly as long as Boar did Also for the reason mentioned above by ToR, which I had not thought about.

[Skipper]

Boar, i dont think he taught Martin all the sword tricks he knew plus Boar was a born fighter and he was bigger and stronger, he was clever so even after all the tricks he taught Martin he could probably still beat Martin

[Superdreuzel]

Poor martin, noone has faith in him:p

[Melody]

I have faith in Martin, at least he became a guiding spirit to Redwall when he died, Boar didn't become a spirit to guide salamondastron, as o matter o fact none of the badger lords did. whoever did this thread should've done something like Martin the warrior vs. Matthias or Boar vs. Lady Cregga.

[Skipper]

Yes but Salamandastron never needed a spirit to guide them, they always saw the enemy coming either from the mountain or on a patrol

[Tiria Wildlough]

Yes but Salamandastron never needed a spirit to guide them, they always saw the enemy coming either from the mountain or on a patrol

Boar would still win, though, because he taught Martin, and still had a lot of tricks to spare. Besides, he was just bigger and stronger.

[GeminyaTome]

All badgers are considered the strongest of all the animals. They always come to the top. The only badger that ever "failed" to win, that I can remember, was Lord Brocktree's father. Martin was a champion sword master, but a badger always wins.

[Sheep-From-The-Red-Hill]

All badgers are considered the strongest of all the animals. They always come to the top. The only badger that ever "failed" to win, that I can remember, was Lord Brocktree's father. Martin was a champion sword master, but a badger always wins.

Slipp an average sea rat killed Mellus with a kitchen knife.

[Melody]

ah good point!

[Skipper]

yes but mother mellus was no warrior and was not armed, she was taken by suprise

[Sheep-From-The-Red-Hill]

yes but mother mellus was no warrior

Neither is Slipp.

and was not armed,

She was probably twice his size.

she was taken by suprise

Actually she jumped Slipp when he threatened the dibbuns so she just got owned fair and square.