What if Rose had lived?

[MatthiasMan]

You kinda ruin the hopes that Rose lived Tiria. (well almost)

[WildDoogyPlumm]

Well, in the TV series at the end it has Grumm putting flowers on her grave.  Sorry, but I don't think she lived.

[MatthiasMan]

Hmf. I just wish she could have dug her way out and had a child or something. that would be a good way to say that Matthias actually WAS related to Martin.

[KaiTheDog]

That implies that Rose may have been buried alive

[MatthiasMan]

I mean if like she came back to life.

[psybox]

nope, sorry.  can't take that idea seriously.
PS. how would that happen?

[Tiria Wildlough]

Says who!? There have been some MIRACULOUS recoveries in the series. This would be an easy one!

If she had lived, a lot of people (including me) would complain about how she was invincible and everything.

You kinda ruin the hopes that Rose lived Tiria. (well almost)

She didn't live. It says in the book that she died.

[MatthiasMan]

Eeerrr. Nev mind.......Look I'm just stating IF. That doesn't mean inevitably. And I said WISH she had dug her way out. That doesn't mean it had to happen.

[redwallgurl]

her wounds were already pretty strong they would have seen a shallow breath or something martin and some healers would try to save ehr but it wouldnt work

[Dannflower Reguba]

Are you guys all serious!!!?

Well, in the TV series at the end it has Grumm putting flowers on her grave.  Sorry, but I don't think she lived.

So umm when did the T.V. series become an expert on what happened?

I mean if like she came back to life.

That's a bit far-fetched

her wounds were already pretty strong they would have seen a shallow breath or something martin and some healers would try to save ehr but it wouldnt work

There is this condition called a COMA it is were life signs can NOT be found!!! A coma could have resulted from the blow (especially if DEATH could have resulted from  a blow like that  )

And Tiria...... What is there to complain about!!!!!?? This is something that should make Redwall fans HAPPY. I don't like invincible characters either, but i don't like ones that can be dispatched by being thrown into a wall by a tired creature!!

[MatthiasMan]

My point is I wish Rose lived.

[KaiTheDog]

Are you guys all serious!!!?

Well, in the TV series at the end it has Grumm putting flowers on her grave.  Sorry, but I don't think she lived.

So umm when did the T.V. series become an expert on what happened?

I mean if like she came back to life.

That's a bit far-fetched

her wounds were already pretty strong they would have seen a shallow breath or something martin and some healers would try to save ehr but it wouldnt work

There is this condition called a COMA it is were life signs can NOT be found!!! A coma could have resulted from the blow (especially if DEATH could have resulted from  a blow like that  )

And Tiria...... What is there to complain about!!!!!?? This is something that should make Redwall fans HAPPY. I don't like invincible characters either, but i don't like ones that can be dispatched by being thrown into a wall by a tired creature!!

I don't recall Badrang being tired when he killed her, but even if he was the adrenaline in his system would've hidden it pretty well.

[Dannflower Reguba]

Someone who has been running and fighting around is INEVITABLY tired..... Needless to say, when I think of Rose, I shall always complete the story in a way were she lives to meet Martin again.

[Tiria Wildlough]

Here is a fanfiction about Rose surviving being thrown against the wall, and she has head trauma. Just thought you might be interested. Be warned, though, it's a bit disturbing.

[Dannflower Reguba]

Did she live in that!? I can't tell. It sounds like she dies at the end in that one too!