Saddest moment

[Log-a-Log]

the saddest moment is when Sayna and part of Luke's tribe is slaughtered in The Legend of Luke

[daskar666]

I don't really cry to much while reading Redwall. Rose is really sad, but anyone dying is sad.

Me too.  I know this isn't really in the spirit of the thing, but it's hard for me to get upset when the characters die.  After all, they are just rodents.  Still, this is why Redwall is appropriate for young readers so I don't really mind it.

That's the reason I imagine all the characters as people. The only characters that I'm unable to do that with are the birds and the snakes which I just imagine as giant talking equivalents of their real world counterparts. On topic, I NEVER cry during books, movies etc, but the Legend of Luke is probably the saddest Redwall book (that's why Brian probably made books 1 and 3 about martin tho I'd certainly prefer to have it all about Luke)

[Icefire]

I don't really cry to much while reading Redwall. Rose is really sad, but anyone dying is sad.

I almost never cry over books...in fact the last time I cried over a book was a couple of years ago...however, that last book was Martin the Warrior. When I first started the book, I actually predicted that she'd die simply because I read Mossflower before Martin the Warrior and I knew she wasn't there, but by the time she actually died I just couldn't stand to see her die! There are other super sad moments, but I think that one wins it.

[Rizzan]

I never actually been brought to tears by a book except when Fatch dies in the bellmaker I don't why but that moment really struck a cord with me.

[DanielofRedwall]

I never actually been brought to tears by a book except when Fatch dies in the bellmaker I don't why but that moment really struck a cord with me.

. Because Fatch was such a good character. He was so trustworthy. He made a promise and he stuck by it until death. Fatch was awesome.

[Icefire]

I never actually been brought to tears by a book except when Fatch dies in the bellmaker I don't why but that moment really struck a cord with me.

. Because Fatch was such a good character. He was so trustworthy. He made a promise and he stuck by it until death. Fatch was awesome.

Total agreement. He was awesome and I was sad when he died.

[sabretache5611]

I never actually been brought to tears by a book except when Fatch dies in the bellmaker I don't why but that moment really struck a cord with me.

. Because Fatch was such a good character. He was so trustworthy. He made a promise and he stuck by it until death. Fatch was awesome.

Total agreement. He was awesome and I was sad when he died.

same here.

[Scragg the Weasel]

Cuthbert Frunks death is sad because of his daughter, Rose of Noonvale.... need I say more, Finbarr Galedeep, Cregga, Veil, i also think its sad when thura dies such a horrible death, and I absolutely hated Cheesethief for Killing the great Scragg the Weasel... Just because he was better than him at everything! He was captain material that one.

[Scragg the Weasel]

Also i absolute bally have to mention Urthstripe and Luke. Heroes everlasting... Enough Said

[Shellhound]

My two top sad moments are:
1. Rose dying in MTW
2. Finbarr dying in Bellmaker

[ilovemariel]

Rose dying
Viel dying
I actually cried my head off because of that

[daskar666]

Nothing.

[Nightfire]

(sob) wh-when R-rose d-d-dies. (sob) (puts face in paws)

[Log-a-Log]

Another sad moment is in the-SPOILER- Rogue Crew when Swiffo dies. He was so young

[Lutra]

I'm with popular opinion on this one: the death of Rose of Noonvale, after all that was accomplished, Martin loses the one he worked with and made him what he became.