Which book is better: Redwall or Mossflower?

[Dannflower Reguba]

WearAt, Weasel crossed with rat... and steroids. 

[Lutra]

Mossflower is the more coherent story, with a better developed plot.  Remember, Mr. Jacques never really was positive Redwall would ever see publication outside of the school for the blind where he read it to kids.  When Mossflower was written, Mr. Jacques was able to expand on his characters and make the story as a reason for existing (why did Redwall exist?).  It flows better without one-off characters that would not ever fit in Redwall properly (the beaver, the horse, Squire Julian with his farmhouse).  Mossflower is the better written story for those reasons.

[Redwallfan7]

Martin the Warrior is good too, even though it's sad

[Dannflower Reguba]

That's the worst book in the series.

[Redwallfan7]

That's the worst book in the series.

Well that's your opinion, so I can't argue, I think Mariel of Redwall is the weakest in the series

[Dannflower Reguba]

lol... I can agree with you on that!  Bellamker was pretty good though.

[Redwallfan7]

lol... I can agree with you on that!  Bellamker was pretty good though.

I guess

[Felldoh154]

Aww you don't like Mariel? As a kid I always liked swinging a rope around after reading that one

[Redwallfan7]

Aww you don't like Mariel? As a kid I always liked swinging a rope around after reading that one

I just thought that the plot was dull. she was okay

[Felldoh154]

I can't remember the whole thing now, but I do remember mariel

[SableFury]

I like Mariel of Redwall because if Brig Thyme, Colonol Clary, and Hon Rosie.

[Dannflower Reguba]

WHOOOHAHAHAH!

[Felldoh154]

Haha hon Rosie was crazy

[Dannflower Reguba]

I know right!
WHOOHAHMph!
"Rosie, kindly put a clamp on it. Wot!"

[Redwallfan7]

Lol!