Favorite Book Out of These

[Rainshadow]

  That was the saddest part in the book to me!  I nearly cried the first time I read that.

[Redwallfan7]

Is it weird that I ddin't recall that part?

[Leatho Shellhound]

  That was the saddest part in the book to me!  I nearly cried the first time I read that.

Same here.....like when I read about Rose in the last battle in the book Martin the Warrior.

[Redwallfan7]

  That was the saddest part in the book to me!  I nearly cried the first time I read that.

Same here.....like when I read about Rose in the last battle in the book Martin the Warrior.

I kind of have to admit Badrang is cool... no offense. Skalrag is too

[GeminyaTome]

I went with The Long Patrol, on the pole, but I also really liked Taggerung and Marlfox. It's sometimes hard choosing a favorite..... sigh

[Dreamer]

of those, I like the long patrol the best.

[WildDoogyPlumm]

Marlfox.  The plot (the tapestry being taken to a faraway island, and a few kids trying to get it back) was unique, and the characters were well-designed (but when are they not, really?).

[LittleRobin]

Mine also Taggerung and that is my top favorite.

[FunBoy]

I have read all these books, but I like Pearls of Lutra very much. I really enjoyed it the first time I read it, and after rereading it, it holds up better than most of the others from the series.

[Dreamer]

The long patrol.

[phoenixfoden]

i just got the tuggerung

[Cheesethief]

the only one i haven't read yet is taggerung but the other three are some of my favorites in the series. id have to go with long patrol followed closely by pearls

[Tam and Martin]

i just got the tuggerung

Yay!

[Sailears]

Woah, where did you dig this up from?

Tough choice.
I love the Long Patrol because of all the awesome hares, so I voted for that.
Taggerung would be my second choice because of well done characters and a very personal story rather than large battles.

Pearls has an awesome "sidequest" - Tansy, Arven, Piknim and Craklyn are amazing. However I found the "main story" to be a bit dull - I will say I find Grath Longfletch to be a boring, one-dimensional character. Then Martin II is the generic warrior mouse, and Clecky/Gerul while fun are far from the most captivating characters in the series.

I don't rate Marlfox highly to be honest. Overall it is a well constructed story and fun to read. However Redwall feels completely abandoned, and while I like the main cast, I don't find them to be amazing. Janglur Swifteye and Cregga are probably the only two characters I can think of that I properly like in that book.

[Captain Tammo]

The Long Patrol is my favorite book. In my head, I see Tammo as one of those extras you'd see mentioned in another book with an untold story. He was never overpowered or even weilded matin's sword, yet he was a simple hare who learned to be a warrior and that makes him special. By adding characters like Russa Nodrey, Sabertache and Russano, Brian found himself looking at one awesome story!