If it was a movie: Poll

[Buzz_Bumble]

What book would make the best movie?

ALL OF THEM!! Make a series of movies. 
But they have to be made in the correct order ... I can't stand silly series that insist on doing "flashbacks" (it's even worse when they keep flashing back or repeating what happen before the advert break within a single episode!). Even though most of the Redwall stories are stand-alone, it would still help to know who Martin was, etc.

[Vilu Daskar]

Marl fox

[Sailears]

Redwall of course.

It could even be tweaked and updated in the movie, to match the structure of the rest of the series.

[MeadowR]

I think some order would be good. Does need starting with a better known one, of course. Redwall or Martin the Warrior or so.

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Zalamandaztron!

[Ferrousferret]

The Sable Quean. It has a good story with a few decent plot twists, great characters that anyone of any age can really feel for, drama, action & just feels like it would work on a level that most of the other Redwall novels wouldn't.

However, there are 22 novels &, if a movie were to be made, I'd much rather they stuck with the core novels of the series- Redwall, Mattimeo, Pearls of Lutra, Long Patrol, Marlfox &/ or Taggerung. Possibly add Martin the Warrior & Mossflower to that list as prequels.

[rachel25]

The Legend of Luke    all the way I am a Taggerung fan to the end but I am also a TLL fan to the bitter end and I think The Legend Of Luke would be the best film but only if they made Martin the Warrior and Mossflower first and if they made like the made Legend of the Guardians 

[Rusvul]

MARLFOX! I would be so happy if there was a Marlfox movie.

[Tam and Martin]

MARLFOX! I would be so happy if there was a Marlfox movie.

Amen! Marlfox I think is one of the best written Redwall books!

[Mariel]

I choose Marlfox,not because I like it, but because it would be harder to mess it up (it would be hard to have gender changes )

[Shadowed One]

It is hard to decide, but they should start with Redwall, then go to Mossflower, etc.

[Tam and Martin]

It is hard to decide, but they should start with Redwall, then go to Mossflower, etc.

They already have a Redwall, MAttimeo and Martin the Warrior.

[Shadowed One]

They were tv shows. And they were not very good.

[Tam and Martin]

'K

[Blaggut]

I think the Long Patrol, with Tammo and younger Cregga. It would work out well in my mind because it is very actiony.

I agree, lots of action scenes, I can imagine that part where Tammo killed a ferret with a sling shot in the head right now!