who would win?

[Captain Tammo]

You've asked for it, here it is!

Romsca, Captain of the Wavewom in The Pearls of Lutra
Vs.
Sagitar Sawfang, Ublaz's strong left paw from The Pearls of Lutra

Who Would Win!?

[Ungatt Trunn]

I have to go with Romsca.
P.S: You should put a poll in this topic.

[Leatho Shellhound]

Don't kill me, don't even quote my post. Sagitar Sawfang

[Ungatt Trunn]

How about Badrang vs. Zwilt the shade??

Now, that sounds intresting!

[Dannflower Reguba]

I think that they'd both come out dead. They are fairly equal.

[Ungatt Trunn]

I think that they'd both come out dead. They are fairly equal.

But Zwilt has the advantege of stelth, kind of giving him the upper hand.

[Tam and Martin]

Romsca!!!

[Ungatt Trunn]

Romsca!!!

Romsca versus who?

[redwallgurl]

Romsca

[Leatho Shellhound]

Romsca!!!

Romsca versus who?

Um ungatt...

You've asked for it, here it is!

Romsca, Captain of the Wavewom in The Pearls of Lutra
Vs.
Sagitar Sawfang, Ublaz's strong left paw from The Pearls of Lutra

Who Would Win!?

[Romsca]

Romsca!

@Leatho: I promise I won't get upset, (and like you asked I didn't quote), but I'm just a little curious why you chose Sagitar.

I think Romsca would win because

1. Ferrets are bigger than rats
2. Romsca is WAY MORE AGGRESSIVE and probably LOVES to fight
3. She's younger; in this case an advantage
4. She's more awesome than Sagitar
5. She's more macho than Sagitar
6. She would love an excuse to kick a trident rat's butt
7. She's rebellious and doesn't like little rats with oversized forks to be ordering her around
8. (IMHO) She likes Barranca, and Sagitar ordered her to leave the island before he came, and that made her REALLY MAD

[Leatho Shellhound]

I not sure, I think Sagitar went up through the ranks, like Romsca, but she became one of Ublaz's most useful beasts. She most have been a good fighter, and a trident is a dangerous weapon(you might argue that Ungatt Trunn lost to a sword, but still).  Food for thought, give both a chance, in reality they are about the same in there skills as a fighter.

I get your point on this one.

[Ungatt Trunn]

I really think that Romsca would win.

[Romsca]

I love that picture! 

[Captain Tammo]

The Votes Are in Annnd...
Romsca Wins!!!

New Matchup! We are returning to the original matchup of this topic:

Each of the following characters from the following books have been granted a horde of 100 at their command and were given a year to train them however they wished. They had total control of what beasts to recruit or turn away and who got promotions, etc.

Now all of these commanders meet on a very wide field of battle. To the North is a single snow capped mountain. To the East there is a very large pine forest. To the South is a large lake. To the West there are rolling hills.

Here are our commanders:

Redwall: Cluny the Scourge
Mossflower: Tsarmina Greeneyes
Mattimeo: Slagar the Cruel AND General Ironbeak (separate armies)
Mariel of Redwall: Gabool the Wild
Salamandastron: Ferhago the Assassin
Martin the Warrior: Badrang the Tyrant
The Bellmaker: The Urgan Nagru
Outcast of Redwall: Swart Sixclaw
Pearls of Lutra: Ublaz Madeyes
The Long Patrol: Damug Warfang
Marlfox: there's many marlfoxes, let's go with Mokan
The Legend of Luke: Vilu Daskar
Lord Brocktree: Ungatt Trunn
Taggerung: The Juska tribe (100 of them)
Triss: Princess Kurda
Loamhedge: Raga Bol AND I guess you could say Kharanjul (separate armies)
Rakkety Tam: Gulo the Savage
High Rhulain: Riggu Felis
Eulalia!: Vizka Longtooth
Doomwyte: Korvus Skurr
The Sable Quean: Vilaya the Sable Quean AND Zwilt the Shade (separate armies)
The Rogue Crew: Razzid Wearat

So... Of these characters,
Who Would Win!?