Which book is better!

[Swiftstream]

I'd have to go for Marlfox.

I found it intersting that the vermin from the book were so slipery and covert. More so than most of the protaginists of the redwall series. I know the odd character operated like that, Shadow from Redwall springs to mind, but that was the point that caught my attention.

[Ungatt Trunn]

I defunautly like The Legand of Luke better than Marlfox. I think that Marlfox was cindof poorly written, which makes it my least favourite Redwall book.

[Tam and Martin]

It's Outcast of Redwall vs Marlfox

[Ungatt Trunn]

It's Outcast of Redwall vs Marlfox

I know; I was saying that I don't like Marlfox that much.

[Redwallfan7]

I choose Marlfox.

[Tam and Martin]

No one has posted for a while so,

Marfox:3
OoR:3
Tied

Poll Change

Two great stories of creature finding Loamhedge. My vote would go to Mattimeo. I like Bragoon and Saro but I love What goes on at Redwall and the quest.

[Captain Tammo]

Loamhedge. It was so sad!!!

[Tam and Martin]

Yes. But it didn't seem good enough. I like what happens at Redwall and Badredd's gang.

[Tam and Martin]

Sorry for double posting.

Mattimeo:4
Loamhedge:1

Mattimeo is the winner!

Poll change!

I love both of these books but I probably like The Rogue Crew better. The storyline got a little off track but I still think it was better.

[Captain Tammo]

I never really was a fan of Eulalia. Probably because I read so many Redwall books before so I had the style down. I don't regret reading it, but the Rogue Crew was special because it was the last redwall book I read and last one Brian wrote

[Kitsune]

Rogue Crew!

[jake897]

  I have to say that Mossflower is the best book ever due to Jacques exquisite writing and how he made the series so epic and great that Martin the Warrior shined bright than ever!!!

[PrimroseWarrior]

mossflower is freat, gonff was exalent, comical, but not stupid. not a lot of authers can do that.

[Romsca]

Rogue Crew!

[Osu]

I can't possibly pick between Eulalia! and the Rogue Crew, they both have hares!

I'm going with Eulalia anyway. XD