Which book is better!

[rachel25]

I know a couple of people who work for a publisher / distributor. That's also how I sometimes get copies of books pre-release, draft / unedited format, and promotional items. For example, I've got copies of draft book covers that were used by the salespeople when visiting book stores, but they are different ot the final published version. I've also got an unedited proof copy of Triss. I also used to get quite a few free books and can still get some books at staff discount prices from various publishers / distributors.

cool

[Ungatt Trunn]

Rakkety Tam!

[Sailears]

Pearls of Lutra, easy.

It's got some amazing characters, a proper treasure hunt so the Abbey "side story" is a pleasure to read - probably the best treasure hunt in all the books. Some nice songs too...

That's not to say RT is bad  - on the contrary, I love it too - I love the hares in there.

[rachel25]

Pearls of Lutra, easy.

It's got some amazing characters, a proper treasure hunt so the Abbey "side story" is a pleasure to read - probably the best treasure hunt in all the books. Some nice songs too...

That's not to say RT is bad  - on the contrary, I love it too - I love the hares in there.

YAY another Pearls fan 

[Tam and Martin]

Alright! I know I have left this topic die for awhile but I'm gonna bring it back and see how it does. I am starting the whole thing over so All the books will be up against each other like we started out with so...


                           NEW ROUND!


First books up against eachother:

The Sable Quean vs. Mattimeo

Begin!

I am going with The Sable Quean on this one. In my opinion, it has more description and better characters.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

Mattimeo!!!

[Dannflower Reguba]

       I'm going with Mattimeo simply because I downright hated the Sable Queen. The shrew drove me up the wall, the main characters didn't do much, and they killed Flandor! Mattimeo I found more intriguing anyway. (Also, I hated the Sable Queen in a way that I'd still read it, I just hated it in relation to the other books)

[rachel25]

Mattimeo defiantly. Sable Quean didn't interest me as much.

[Wylder Treejumper]

Mattimeo! far better characters and a very menacing villain, even if Slagar's demise was a bit weak.

[Shadowed One]

Sable Quean!

[Leatho Shellhound]

I enjoyed the Sable Quean very much, but I like both of them.

[The Mask]

Sable Quean. I really liked Buckler an' whatshisface. To be honest I didn't really enjoy Redwall and Mattimeo.

[Russa Nodrey]

Hmm, I'd say I liked The Sable Quean better than Mattimeo, although both were cool.

[Russano the Wise]

Although I really enjoyed both books, I think my favorite was probably Mattimeo.

[Leatho Shellhound]

Sable Quean. I really liked Buckler an' whatshisface. To be honest I didn't really enjoy Redwall and Mattimeo.

Meliton Gubthorpe Digglethwaite, or Diggs for short.