Sherlock (BBC show)

[Gonff the Mousethief]

That's one of the great things about this show. One, Sherlock hates to wear the hat he is known for in the stories, and two, Watson tells Sherlock all this stuff from Elemetary school, where as in the stories Sherlock says Elemetary my dear Watson. Very clever Moffat!

[rachel25]

Yeah. I like how more....emtional....(not sure if thats the right word) they made him in serise three.

[MeadowR]

Sherlock never said 'Elementary, Dear Watson' in the books, as far as I'm aware? And of course the deer-stalker hat, cloak and such were not in the original novels, either.

I preferred the tone of the first two series. The third was still good. I am most intrigued how the next series will pan out. (And when!)

[Jetthebinturong]

It's a good series, not as good as either the Jeremy Brett or Robert Downey Junior films of course, but good nonetheless

[Søren]

I never saw the Jeremy Britt ones, but I think these are better then the Downey Jrs. I suppose Jude Law did a good Watson, but these are a little less dark. Maybe it's because I prefer shows that aren't so morbid.

[Hickory]

I never saw the Jeremy Britt ones, but I think these are better then the Downey Jrs. I suppose Jude Law did a good Watson, but these are a little less dark. Maybe it's because I prefer shows that aren't so morbid.

I love the downy jr.ones

[The Mask]

The movies are pretty good. But I really think Benedict Cumberbach is better.

[Søren]

The movies are pretty good. But I really think Benedict Cumberbach is better.

I agree, plus, the TV show had a lot more content. Only two movies, and 9 hour-and-a-half long episodes.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Sherlock never said 'Elementary, Dear Watson' in the books, as far as I'm aware? And of course the deer-stalker hat, cloak and such were not in the original novels, either.

I preferred the tone of the first two series. The third was still good. I am most intrigued how the next series will pan out. (And when!)

I've read maybe 20 or so of the original Sherlock stories (by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle), and he has never said it once, I'm pretty sure I heard somewhere that Sherlock never said that in the original stories, and that it was just added later in some adaption to the stage or something like that.

[Delthion]

Jeremy Brett is the only true Sherlock Holmes. Wow, that sounds like I'm in a cult!

[Ungatt Trunn]

Jeremy Brett is the only true Sherlock Holmes. Wow, that sounds like I'm in a cult!

I honestly feel Robert Downey Jr. makes the best Sherlock: not exactly for the way he acted him out in the movies, but for the reason that he looks just like I imagined Sherlock while reading the books.

[Delthion]

Well, I think that I actually imagined Holmes to look just like Jeremy Brett, and I had not watched the series that he was in by that time.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Well, I think that I actually imagined Holmes to look just like Jeremy Brett, and I had not watched the series that he was in by that time.

Same here, just with Downey Jr. 

[Leatho Shellhound]

I'm holding you all responsible....


I watched the first ep. ........ I like it!

[The Mask]

Good good. If you didn't I'd have to kill you