whos the best warrior in redwall good or bad

[rakkety tam]

post anything u want to

[James Gryphon]

The most skilled hero, Boar.

The most skilled villain, Cluny.

[DanielofRedwall]

Heroes: I voted Martin the Warrior number 1, obviously, he is amazing. Rakkety Tam is number 2 because he is very skilled and just awesome! Boar would have to be right up there, if I had a third vote I'd go for him. I think Matthias would be up there as well, but he isn't on the list (and, to be honest, I'm not sure why).
Villains: Cluny the Scourge would be the best, honouabke mentions to Gabool, Badrang and Damug Warfang.

Why is Badredd on that list, by the way, because he wasn't a very good warrior...?

[rakkety tam]

I voted Martin the Warrior number 1, obviously, he is amazing. Rakkety Tam is number 2 because he is very skilled and just awesome!

Why is Badredd on that list, by the way, because he wasn't a very good warrior...

i dont know i thought i should just put him on there and plus i couldnt remember anyother bad guys at the moment

[Gonff]

I'll say the Taggerung because he was very good at tracking and fighting. My 2nd will be Trisscar because she was good too and she took care of her friends, etc.

[Log-a-Log]

I think the Taggerung was the most talented warrior- he could swim better than anyone, could track anybody down, and of course was a fierce fighter

[daskar666]

Gulo (for obvious reasons) and MTW.
Regarding Tagg, although he was doubtlessly a skilled warrior, we didn't actually see him in any battles (except the fight with Yo Karr).
Which is a pity (because of his warrior skills). I wonder if hope there's an unpublished book about Tagg, Ruggan Bor and Russano which is a sequel to Taggerung.

[Captain Tammo]

I chose Bragoon and Saro because they held back a full army over an abyss

[Luath]

I voted for Rakkety Tam (what can I say, I'm a Scot) but I actually dont have a favorite and think all the warriors (the warriors of good anyway) are all as amazing as each other.   

[sabretache5611]

Rakkety tam is highly skilled with several weapons so thats why i voted for him.  Tagg is trained in all manner of tracking and hand to hand combat.  he could also capture Juskarath alive and bring them back without hurting them, quite a mark of skill.  Martin is also very good, but...he lacks in size advantage compared to tagg and tam

[Lutra]

I think the list is a tad short, but I put votes in for Tagg and Lady Cregga.  You don't get in the way of badgers in bloodrath...even if the fighting eventually causes you to lose your vision later in life.

[martins#1fan]

I voted Martin the Warrior number 1, obviously, he is amazing. Rakkety Tam is number 2 because he is very skilled and just awesome!

Why is Badredd on that list, by the way, because he wasn't a very good warrior...

Martin the Warrior of course!! He was the Abbey Warrior!! You have to be awesome to be the abbey warrior!
Martin is the most skilled Warrior of them ALL, NOT Boar the Fighter.
You've gotta' vote For Martin!

[Taggerung_of_Redwall]

I think the list is a tad short

A fix would be to just add an 'Other' option

And for a villain, the most skilled in sword would be Kurda. In bow, I'd say Vallug Bowbeast, followed by Dingeye.
I couldn't say hero.
This topic wasn't specified by 'best', and the name of the game seems to be most talented, though it could be interpreted as just whoever someone's favorite warrior-classed character.

[martins#1fan]

I think the list is a tad short

A fix would be to just add an 'Other' option

And for a villain, the most skilled in sword would be Kurda. In bow, I'd say Vallug Bowbeast, followed by Dingeye.
I couldn't say hero.
This topic wasn't specified by 'best', and the name of the game seems to be most talented, though it could be interpreted as just whoever someone's favorite warrior-classed character.

What? Clearly the Most skilled with a sword is Martin, with Lord Brocktree a close second, and Rakkety Tam a close third.

[Taggerung_of_Redwall]

First off, I specifically said as for a villain the most skilled. I was not counting in any heroes, as I couldn't decide about them.
And that's a matter of opinion.