BadRed

[rachel25]

I'm not sure maybe hetruly ad because of his upbringing but I think I'll vote yes 

[Redwaller]

Badredd was stupid, and bad.

[rachel25]

Yeah was that b/c everyone was mean to him but yeah he was stupid

[Tam and Martin]

Well, you think about what he was going to do if he got into Redwall so yes.

[Shadowed One]

He was more of a comic villain, totally inept and even though his intentions were evil, he was hilarious.

[rachel25]

He wouldn't have every taken Redwall the otters would have slain him and his crew in fact the only reason he ever got into the grounds was because of a freak accident 

[Vilu Daskar]

Maybe

[rachel25]

I voted Well what do you think.... YES!   
Yes   -3 (33.3%)
No   -0 (0%)
Maybe   -1 (11.1%)
Of course he was   -2 (22.2%)
No not at all I love him   -2 (22.2%)
Well what do you think.... YES!   -1 (11.1%)

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Naybeazt iz ever "truly" bad. Zere actionz an' planz may be conzidered wrong, but ze creaturez zemzelvez arenae bad.

[BadgerLordFiredrake]

Naybeazt iz ever "truly" bad. Zere actionz an' planz may be conzidered wrong, but ze creaturez zemzelvez arenae bad.

That could be debated.

Yea, he was one of the closest baddy leader to get into Redwall, but it was accidental.  Nevertheless, he caused a rather large crisis.

[Samkim]

which book is he in?

[Tam and Martin]

Loamhedge. He is one of the vermin who try to get into Redwall.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Its evident that he was bad. Non of his actions in the book he appeared him showed him to have a single good quality inside.

[The Shade]

I can't remember much, so I voted maybe.

[rachel25]

Yes   -4 (30.8%)
No   -1 (7.7%)
Maybe   -3 (23.1%)
Of course he was   -2 (15.4%)
No not at all I love him   -2 (15.4%)
Well what do you think.... YES!   -1 (7.7%)