Should there be guns in Redwall

[Maudie]

You know what I feel like saying to this topic?

WELL THERE AREN'T GUNS IN REDWALL, SO LIVE WITH IT!!!!!!!!

[The Shade]

NO! Absolutely not, and that squirrel is ugly with a gun.

YOU were the one that made the modern redwall rp!!!

RPs and Fanfics are okay, but others say that they would have liked Brian to put guns.

Yeah, guess your right.

[Emperor Ublaz]

NEVER!!!! A weapon like that would DESTROY the entire medieval feeling of Redwall. Also, heroes such as Martin the Warrior would have almost no chance against an enemy with a gun. Furthermore, if a vermin leader got his hands on some heavy artillery, he could completely level the abbey.

[Maudie]

NEVER!!!! A weapon like that would DESTROY the entire medieval feeling of Redwall. Also, heroes such as Martin the Warrior would have almost no chance against an enemy with a gun. Furthermore, if a vermin leader got his hands on some heavy artillery, he could completely level the abbey.

I agree, and welcome to the forum, Ublaz!

[Romsca]

Like I said, maybe they tried them, and it was such a pain to load them and they were so inaccurate they stopped using them. I still think I could put them in a fanfic in such a way that it's still canon

[Redwaller]

But we have to think that Redwall is set in the late Medieval - beginning Renaissance, when guns did not still exist. And it is as if this Era does not move, while history unravels forth the mighty adventures of our Heros.

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

May'apz, like Romsca zaid, a long time agae zey 'ad gunz an' gunpovder, but eventually zomezin' 'appened tae end ziz, like zey ran oot o' ammo or vere zae difficult tae uze (alzae like Romsca zaid) zat zey juzt melted ze gunz intae molten zlag an' made zem intae zvordz an' ze lot. May'apz zomebeazt blev zemzelvez up viz it an' ze entire ztore'ouze o' gunpovder vent KABLOOIE!

[rachel25]

But we have to think that Redwall is set in the late Medieval - beginning Renaissance, when guns did not still exist. And it is as if this Era does not move, while history unravels forth the mighty adventures of our Heroes

yeah but what if Redwall moved into the Georgian era

[Redwaller]

Redwall does not move, it stays in what Era it is, and doesn't move.

But if you study Redwall closely, you can see that it has modern things in it, like the food is pretty modern.

[rachel25]

*nods head*

[Faiyloe]

I don't think there should be guns in Redwall They take no skill there is nothing noble about them. I am making a Fan fiction with one of my friends. He has a character from the future of Redwall and he has a gun. 

[rachel25]

Not noble have you seen Les Miserable 

[Tam and Martin]

I think what she means is some of the guns today where it's a mass kill like machine guns, rapid-firing guns, and big bomb-like guns. They take out a lot of people but they aren't "noble".

[Faiyloe]

It doesn't take much skill to weld a gun whereas a sword or bow and arrows take more talent. Guns make things too easy.   

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

It doesn't take much skill to weld a gun whereas a sword or bow and arrows take more talent. Guns make things too easy.   

Nae tae mention mezzy tae boot!