What's the most Tragic Event in Redwall

[Norham Waterpaw]

 Yeah, that was probably my first main character death experience. I'm like "Yay, Methuselah, You cool dude, oh, you're dead."

[rachel25]

Yeah I was more disappointed than sad when Methuselah died. I was like.
"What, huh, why, oh bless him. Poor guy." 

[Banya Streamdog]

 I think Rose's death very sad.

[rachel25]

And the death of Mask 

[Tam and Martin]

And the death of Mask 

Yeah...

[Ferrousferret]

The climax of Legend of Luke.

[CrazyPug37]

The deaths of Rose, Veil, and Mask were the most tragic in my opinion.

[rachel25]

I didn't mind to much when Veil died. I felt it more like justice. He did try to kill the Friar after all.

[Skyblade]

The climax of Legend of Luke.

Yep ^^

[Rusvul]

Bragoon and Saro's death. Very sadfacey.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

What about jukka and fleetscut???

[Wylder Treejumper]

There are tons of tragic deaths in Redwall... the young'uns that died in the battles of the Long Patrol always hit me pretty hard, though.

[321tumbler]

Methusalah, Mask, Saro, Bragoon, and Rose are probably high on the list, but there are more. I also thought St. Ninians was sad.

[Blazemane]

The climax of Legend of Luke.

Yep ^^

My first instinct is this, too. Luke tries to steer Vilu Daskar's ship back to his own home, only to find that everything's been completely abandoned--and not cleanly either, like every one was forced to leave suddenly (Martin, his grandmother and Timballisto are all enslaved at this point, for example). So Luke only sees the option of going down with the ship.

But I wonder about the first Mossflower revolution under Barkstripe, too...

[Emperor Ublaz]

Not Brigadier Crumshaw! NOOOOO!!!!!!!!!