The Legend Of Luke - General Book Discussion

[Ungatt Trunn]

I've just finished re-reading The Legend Of Luke, and it was better than I remember it being! It had a real adventure feel to it, which I haven't really felt since I started reading The Hobbit. I also like how the middle of the book is about Luke, and the rest is about Martin's travels. That is probably the biggest contributor to the adventure feel of it all. I also think that the main plotline was very, VERY well done. The only one that surpasses it in my book is Martin The Warrior. Over all, I think its a great book! Comments?

[Vilu Daskar]

I like the best part is when it talks about Luke

[Ungatt Trunn]

I like the best part is when it talks about Luke

Yes, I think that that is one of the main highlights of the book.

[Faiyloe]

I thought it was well written but I didn't like how it was two different story's. Luke's story was to short and it seemed to interrupt the flow of Martins story. Martins half of the story also seemed to lack a main villein which made it lose a lot of the adventure feel. On the other hand I really liked Luke's story. It had like you said an adventure feel which I think made up for the lack of it in the other half of the book.    

[Ungatt Trunn]

I thought it was well written but I didn't like how it was two different story's. Luke's story was to short and it seemed to interrupt the flow of Martins story. Martins half of the story also seemed to lack a main villein which made it lose a lot of the adventure feel. On the other hand I really liked Luke's story. It had like you said an adventure feel which I think made up for the lack of it in the other half of the book.    

I sort of think the opposite. I liked how there was two different story lines. It sort of gave it the true feeling of being realistic. 

[Emperor Ublaz]

I agree with Ungatt. The double storyline was unique. No other Redwall book that I have read possesses that.

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

An' bezidez, ze book vaz zuppozed tae be aboot Luke Ze Varrior anyvay. Martin'z tvo partz lacked a villian becauze zey didnae need vone. Ze ztory vaz Luke'z, zae 'iz vaz ze vone viz ze main villian in it.

[Faiyloe]

I think what I was trying to say was that Martins story took up most of the book and with out a villein I lost interest before I could get to the good stuff. I really wish he had made Luke's story longer.

[rachel25]

I like Folgrim and Chugger's friendship in the book

[Tam and Martin]

No offense to all those who liked it but it is near the bottom for my list of favorite Redwall books. I't good yes! but not as good as the others I think.

[Ungatt Trunn]

o offense to all those who liked it but it is near the bottom for my list of favorite Redwall books. I't good yes! but not as good as the others I think.

Its currently my number 2 book...but we all have different opinions.

[The Shade]

I think what I was trying to say was that Martins story took up most of the book and with out a villein I lost interest before I could get to the good stuff. I really wish he had made Luke's story longer.

Same, I really liked Lukes adventure, and wished it was longer...

[Ungatt Trunn]

I thought it was well written but I didn't like how it was two different story's. Luke's story was to short and it seemed to interrupt the flow of Martins story.

But the main point of Martin's side of the adventure was to find out what happened to his father.

[Russano the Wise]

Right now The Legend of Luke is one of my favorite Redwall books. When I first read it a long time ago I didn't think much about it. It was a good book but not one of my favorites. But when I re-read it a month or two ago I really loved it. Luke had some great quotes and the book also contained one of my favorite Redwall quotes ever. You can see it in my signature.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Right now The Legend of Luke is one of my favorite Redwall books. When I first read it a long time ago I didn't think much about it. It was a good book but not one of my favorites. But when I re-read it a month or two ago I really loved it. Luke had some great quotes and the book also contained one of my favorite Redwall quotes ever. You can see it in my signature.

I think that quote was the best one in the whole book! True wisdom it had to it.