the 'what if' game

[James Gryphon]

I would have gotten tired of her much more quickly.

What if Rasconza and Guja didn't survive when their ship went down?

[Tiria Wildlough]

Then Ublaz would have gotten his wish. The wave vermin would have had no leader, and would have been easier to destroy.
What if Nightfire wasn't obsessed with Ranguvar Foeseeker?

[Nightfire]

The world would end, and you with it. 

What if people actually were as obssessed with Ranguvar Foeseeker as I am?

[Tiria Wildlough]

I would keel over and die.
What if the above actually happened?

[Nightfire]

We would all be incredibly sad, and hold a huge funeral. Then I'd steal your High Rhulain armor. 

What if Slagar the Cruel did not get bitten by Asmodeus?

[Taggerung The Otter]

he would still be alive!
what i BJ never made a REDWALL book

[Nightfire]

Then this would be a Castaways of the Flying Dutchman forum instead.
(SPOILER: Chickenhound didn't die.)

What if Matthias the Warrior had never been born?

(hoping for one of James' essays again. )

[winifred]

then redwall itself wouldnt exist for that was the start of it all
what if...cluny died from the fall out of that tree

[Tiria Wildlough]

There would be no book called Redwall. Matthias wouldn't have become a warrior until General Ironbeak came along.
What if Plugg Firetail had killed Princess Pinkeyes?

[Plugg Firetail]

Then I would have become the most famous villain ever.

What if I was the most famous villain ever?

[Tiria Wildlough]

I would probably have done battle with you before now.
What if Ranguvar Foeseeker had never been born?

[KaiTheDog]

Then there would be one less bloodrathy squirrel

What if Brome never ran away from Noonvale?

[Tiria Wildlough]

There would be way less people mooning over Rose of Noonvale.
What if Salamandastron was a vermin fort?

[Plugg Firetail]

Then Redwall would be taken over.

What if I didn't change my siggie?

[Tiria Wildlough]

We wouldn't know any better.
What if Askor had survived?