the 'what if' game

[Vulpin]

something my friends and i played on tribal wars and on thread sites similar to this... Its very simple. it starts with a what if question, and then the next person awnsers and gives another for someone else to awnser.

[example:

player1: what is spiderman got stung by a radioactive scorpian?

player2: he wouldnt be call spider man
               what if books was never invented?

       And so on]

Since this is a site from which the series of redwall is revolved around, the only rule is that you keep it redwall based.

I'll start, and hope you all have a good time...

[taken from the first book]
What if the pitch black rat, 'Shadow', lived threw the fall and escaped?

[rakkety tam]

he would have attempted to kill cluny
wat if dotti never left home

[Icefire]

Salamandastron would be doomed

What if Mattimeo hadn't been taken captive?

[Skalrag of Marshank]

Then Mattimeo would still be a spoiled brat, and the story would suck.

[Trigoma]

"blank"

what if rocangus had never been found by thrugg and dumble?

[Nightfire]

He would have been eaten by an adder.

What if someone here actually knew what Metroiud Prime was and actually loves to play it. (like me)

[Redwall Musician]

What if someone here actually knew what Metroiud Prime was and actually loves to play it. (like me)

I don't know what that is. Remember, we got to keep this Redwall based.

Since this is a site from which the series of redwall is revolved around, the only rule is that you keep it redwall based.

[rakkety tam]

wat if gulos brother lived

[Skalrag of Marshank]

I dunno. I haven't read Rakkety Tam yet.

[rakkety tam]

I dunno. I haven't read Rakkety Tam yet.

then why did u reply

[Skalrag of Marshank]

Because I felt like it. Heehee.

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Yoofuz Wid never have found "The Walking Stone".

Wha' if Cluny had ztepped oat o' the way o' the bell?

[Skalrag of Marshank]

Matthias would probably break all of his fingers punching a brick wall. And I would be happy.

[Nightfire]

What if Skalrag had been a goodbeast?

[Skalrag of Marshank]

Then I would be overjoyed. I don't think goodbeasts get tickled to death all that often...