Mafia Discussion

[Skyblade]

A thread in which we can talk about the game of Mafia!

Just one rule: DO NOT talk about ongoing games. That's called cheating

Ongoing Games

Mafia III (Cornflower MM)
Salamandastron Mafia (rrrrr)
Town of Salem (Sagetip, the hare)

[close]

Completed Games

Mafia (Skyblade)
Mafia II (Rainshadow)
Mafia 2.5 (Sagetip, the hare)
Mafia 3.5 (Eulaliaaa!)

[close]

You can also use this as a rant/vent thread.

You guys probably don't know as much about Mafia as I do, but again, I really appreciate compliments/ constructive criticism. I've played in Mafia Round 2 (ongoing) and 2.5 (killed Night 1, I've got some bad luck), if you want to see my posts.

[Banya]

Gonff and I were a great Mafia duo during Round 1.  I was really enjoying it.

I play "Town of Salem" often while I'm home, and I have the lucky/unlucky ability (depending on how you view it) to be overlooked.  In real life Mafia, I am always accused of being the Mafia, because, to quote my friends, "You're just the quiet killer type."  I'm still trying to figure out what that means.

[Hickory]

@Banya: I've recently been reading the Flavia De Luce series and in it, the Inspector notes that "Your average murderer generally gives the police as wide a berth as possible..."

That help?

Anyway, half of the chance of you getting killed is down to luck. The other half is acting right. I ca only say that if you observe and learn, you should do better.

Also, I think when I said that there might be clues in the story that all players just kind of overanalysed. 

[Skyblade]

I guess so, Sage I know this is just a game, but I like it and I want to be good. Maybe someday. The future is so cryptic.

I am trying, though. And I am improving in my opinion.

[Hickory]

Poker face.

[Eulaliaaa!]

Sky, if you're Medic, it's a good idea to protect yourself the first few nights. For one, you're a valuable player that people need. And two, there's so many people at the beginning of the game that the chances of you saving the person being attacked are very small. So why take the chance? I would wait until you see someone making a target of themselves, then save them and hope you're not helping the Mafia. That's just what I would do, and I'm not saying you did anything wrong. I know you're better at Mafia than me, you've had a lot more practice  

Also, wouldn't it be fun to play a Redwall Mafia after these two rounds are done? Same game, just based off of Redwall. Maybe set in a Guosim camp...

[Hickory]

... Like Outcast? With Swartt? That'd be cool...

[Skyblade]

Eul, that's a good idea, thank you. And thank you for the encouragement.

I think you're great, especially for someone who's just starting out.

I've acrually thought of Redwall Mafia too! Good idea. We should do that next round

[Hickory]

... but as a roleplay!

[Skyblade]

Who wants to narrate the Redwall Mafia round? I won't, because I want to plaaaay.

[Eulaliaaa!]

I could, I've been wanting to have a go at being Narrator anyway. That way I can choose who is who and all that 

And Sage, what do you mean by roleplay?

[Hickory]

Nevermind, I said that without thinking.

[Skyblade]

Sounds great, Eul Usually the Narrator is supposed to randomize the roles, but I guess you could choose.

Anyway, do you guys have a favorite role? Mine's probably Vigilante. It hasn't been used in a forum game yet, but it's a Citizen who can kill someone at Night.

[rrrrr]

 

[Skyblade]

What's wrong, Rrrrr?