POLL: If These Badgers were in a fight, who would win

[Jetthebinturong]

He was strong-willed, extremely intelligent and had a nearly flawless plan. He also had an interesting backstory and a personal grudge against the main characters rather than being a random, uninteresting horde leader.

[Ashleg]

Slagar.

I don't really understand why so many people seem to like Slagar, I fail to see what was special about him. Can someone please enlighten me?

Finally, another with the same opinion! High five!

[alexandre]

 

Slagar.

I don't really understand why so many people seem to like Slagar, I fail to see what was special about him. Can someone please enlighten me?

Finally, another with the same opinion! High five!

[Ashleg]

Slagar.

I don't really understand why so many people seem to like Slagar, I fail to see what was special about him. Can someone please enlighten me?

Finally, another with the same opinion! High five!

I guess Afro icons will do. XD

[alexandre]

Slagar.

I don't really understand why so many people seem to like Slagar, I fail to see what was special about him. Can someone please enlighten me?

Finally, another with the same opinion! High five!

I guess Afro icons will do. XD

I suppose, they are my fav. 

[Aimless Gallivanter]

why isnt dear old crazy cloggo am option??

[Kitsune]

While I greatly like the character Plugg Firetail, I'm not sure if he constitutes as a villain or a grey character. Regardless, I voted for him.

[alexandre]

why isnt dear old crazy cloggo am option??

He lost to Badrang,  I voted for Clogg but he sadly lost 

Right now I'm only polling the winners of all the previous polls, then I will poll the losers, after that I'm thinking of changing this topic to a completely different poll. Also, it would be nice if someone moved this topic into Character discussion.

[Delthion]

Nobody else thinks Swartt Sixclaw was a good villain? His only mistake (That I remember.) was to fight on unfavorable terrain in the final battle.

[Ashleg]

He was a good villain and that's about it.
Besides being a flunk husband and father, there was really nothing that stood out about his personality besides his strength.

[Delthion]

He was a good villain and that's about it.
Besides being a flunk husband and father, there was really nothing that stood out about his personality besides his strength.

Isn't that what we're voting about?

He was also very clever, more clever than most of the villains in the books, mainly with the poisoning of that Warlord using the goblet.

[Jetthebinturong]

Redwall's villains are one of it's weak points. They are mostly uninteresting with no motivation or reason and are just evil because of the inherent nature of their species. They rarely ever have personal histories with the protagonists and are mainly just a menacing force off in the distance.

Swartt was a good villain. By Redwall standards. However, nothing much about his personality stands out.

I voted for Ungatt Trunn because I've realised I honestly don't care about most of Redwall's villains, but in retrospect I should have voted Slagar.

[Ashleg]

He was a good villain and that's about it.
Besides being a flunk husband and father, there was really nothing that stood out about his personality besides his strength.

Isn't that what we're voting about?

He was also very clever, more clever than most of the villains in the books, mainly with the poisoning of that Warlord using the goblet.

By that I meant he was good at being evil and that's it.
They were all clever for the most part.

I voted Vilu because he's classy and awesome.

[Delthion]

Good at being evil is what a villain is supposed to be. But I understand what you are saying.

[alexandre]

He was a good villain and that's about it.
Besides being a flunk husband and father, there was really nothing that stood out about his personality besides his strength.

Isn't that what we're voting about?

He was also very clever, more clever than most of the villains in the books, mainly with the poisoning of that Warlord using the goblet.

By that I meant he was good at being evil and that's it.
They were all clever for the most part.

I voted Vilu because he's classy and awesome.

The spoiler is of Lord Brocktree and The Legend of Luke. I don't know how to say what the spoiler is of inside the little spoiler icon , if someone could inform me that would be great.

Spoiler

I picked Trunn, I feel like Trunn and Vilu were the most important villains in the books. They are the reason Redwall and Salamandastron became so strong. Salamandastron is more obvious, Ungatt was the reason that eventually the long patrol was founded and has been protecting the shores since. Without Vilu, Luke never would have left Martin, Martin would have never met Rose (although that would save me a lot of tears ), and Redwall might never have been (though eventually I'm sure someone would save the woodlanders), but it wouldn't be the same. I ultimately chose Ungatt who seemed to have more success, though Vilu might have if Luke hadn't made his final sacrifice.

[close]