Mafia: The James Edition

[Jetthebinturong]

Personally, I think Galli is the Doctor, due to her immediately going after Sky when she found out she was gone.

[Groddil]

Personally, I think Galli is the Doctor, due to her immediately going after Sky when she found out she was gone.

That does make sense. If Galli was Blue Mafia, she would have just pulled a Delthion, to make it quicker.

[James Gryphon]

Do the girls at any point have access to the guys room and vice versa? And may you PM Ashe please? He hasn't posted once.

I did PM Ash, earlier.

As far as your question goes, if anybody did access the other side's room, it obviously didn't happen while most of y'all were awake, else, you would have heard about it. And if anything happened in y'all's sleep, then, of course, you couldn't know.

That said, speaking as somebody who's been on plenty of youth trips, I don't think that your chaperones would let that happen; I personally find the idea quite improper.

New poll is up, just FYI.

[Delthion]

This is how all of the real mafia games go that I have participated in, I am targeted, either the doctor saves me or I die...

[Gonff the Mousethief]

I can't talk a lot about it now, but I'm really feeling that it may be Fatch. He didn't go out, he didn't go anything, which would throw him off the trail. Or it may be Søren, dunno.

[Groddil]

I can't talk a lot about it now, but I'm really feeling that it may be Fatch. He didn't go out, he didn't go anything, which would throw him off the trail. Or it may be Søren, dunno.

I guess. But personally I agree more with the Soren part. Dunno why, just a hunch, but it seems like Fatch always seems a little bit suspicious. Soren, on the other hand, has been pretty defensive. Hmm...

[Gonff the Mousethief]

Another reason I am going to pick between those two is because I would have gotten it a Red Mafia located. That means that the two other Blue Mafia would join in, and the Town would also be a part of it. Plus it seems kind of vague who would be attacking Sky, but I think Eul may be the Doctor.

[Groddil]

'Course, the Blue Mafia might have chosen the role that lets them see what Sky actually was. Even without knowing WHAT she was, they knew that she was either an opposing mafia member, or some sort of townie. Most likely the second option, because why would the doctor save a Red Mafia?

EDIT:

I've got more evidence to suggest Soren as being Blue Mafia. I forgot to bring this up earlier, but just before Del got murdered, he and Soren were both sending messages. The Red Mafia killed Del, who turned out to be mafia, so I'm going to join this with my other findings and vote for Soren.

[Eulaliaaa!]

*Reads story several times* so much info and we have no idea what is and isn't useful. Well, time to pick through every tiny detail, make note of it all and compare it to everything I see

Ok, Sky must be either with Town or Red Mafia. We can narrow it down to that. The story mentions the Doctor that saved her was wearing a hat. I think we should make note of that small detail and see if it appears in the story again, it may give us an idea who our Doctor is.

Del was killed by Red Mafia, one who has to be a boy. James said people of the opposite gender would not be allowed in the rooms, and it would only make sense to have each Mafia team have at least one of each gender unless we're going for the whole "boys vs. girls" thing. Which, if that is the case, means Sky is Town. We might want to read the stories to see if it's a common theme. It might be helpful, maybe not.

Sage was with Sky when Blue Mafia attacked. That doesn't mean he isn't Blue Mafia. It's possible that he and another Blue Mafia were there.
He said "I don't think James liked the idea of you being down here by yourself."
James knew we were down in the lobby getting whatever we needed. Sky, Sage, Gonff, and Galli are at the front desk. As they go back, Sky says she wants ice. Sage and Gonff get back. Sky and Galli get back and Sky goes to get ice after Rain says Rosie and I left to get stuff. Sky leaves. Rain and Galli seem to have some form of authority here because Matthias is talking to them about the schedule and figuring stuff out. So Rain knows Rosie, Sky, and I are all out there together. Sky isn't alone, from what everybody else knows. And when Rosie and I got back, I doubt we'd just peek into the boy's room to find James all like "Wassup, yo? We're going back to the girl's room and stuff, like, we're all cool here no need to be worrying we're back now, BTW, Sky is alone out there!"
So James wouldn't know Sky is alone and wouldn't be able to say so. Sage and Gonff heard Sky say she was getting ice, and they left her. For all they know, Galli would still be with her, and with everybody coming and going, it would be hard to know whether or not she was alone. So maybe Sage went down to go see while one of his Mafia buddies shot at her if there was the opportunity. Urgh, this is hard to organize. Do you guys get what I'm trying to say? And it could mean nothing, I don't know. We can't rely on the story clues, but so far, that's what I've observed. What are your thoughts?

[Chipster of Noonvale]

It's interesting how most of the story focuses on the failed murder attempt on Skyblade, than the successful murder attempt on Delthion.

There aren't many clues as to who killed Del, but I agree that it was probably someone in the same room.  But it could be anyone...

Who tried to kill Skyblade?  There is plenty of info about that, but I have no idea what is a clue and what isn't.

Here is a possible clue: Eul carried four bottles of water.  That's unusual.  Maybe she put blue food colouring in it and attempted to use that to kill Skyblade?

Apart from that, Groddil raises a good point about Søren, and Eul about Sage.

I'm not voting yet, though.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

Okay, so here is something. Could Eul and Rosie maybe both be Blue? Or maybe just Rosie. Because Rosie got Skittles, a candy which can, in time, turn water a color. And depending on the package, she could have A) Taken it and put it in one of Eul's bottles and then loaded the gun, B) They could have both planned it, or C) Eul did what Rosie would have done.

Also, something more on the Del and Fatch thing. I feel that knowing I am not one of the Mafia (I know that's a risky thing to say, but if so, why would I be trying so hard to get someone else out, especially if they may be on my team?), leaves those options with those two clues. And when you look at it, neither Fatch nor Soren get more than a mention about which room they are in. I'm really stuck here now.

[Eulaliaaa!]

That's actually a really good point about the Skittles. Obviously, I disagree with me being involved with it, but that could be something. It's possible that Red is the boys and Blue is the girls. Then again, wouldn't it make sense for the Mafia teams to already be provided their colors and stuff by the people hosting the game? How else would we know what team killed someone if the Mafia can't find anything with their color to kill someone with?

[Groddil]

I disagree about the gender thing. If the mafia teams were both 1-gendered, then once all the town was dead, they'd just stay in their rooms. The only way to kill off the opposing team would be to leave the safety of their room, which also means that the opposing team could kill you. It'd be a ratio of 2:1, yes, but I seriously doubt that either of the teams are completely 1-gendered.

[Eulaliaaa!]

I said it was a possibility, not a cold hard fact

Also, Night comes and Mafia will choose and kill their victim, it's the rules. Staying in the rooms wouldn't do anything.

[Søren]

You're thinking about it as if we could choose what room we're in. The room eludes to who the killer is (assuming the clue is in the rooms), not that the room would be of any protection one way or another.

I like that idea about Eul and the water bottles. Didn't know Skittles changes water color.
I also like what Eul said about Sage. I'm leaning mostly towards Sage.

And I'm sorry for being defensive, I forgot that's a death sentence