Mafia: The James Edition

[Cornflower MM]

It was a choice between you and Eul and sorry, I chose you.

. . . . .

I'm still confused as to why.

[Rosie Willowwater]

I'm voting for Peony today and that's going to take a lot to change. After reading over what went down on Day 2, I am extremely suspicious of her. The way she is acting really suggests that she may be the last Blue Mafia. Also, it's advantageous to the Town to get rid of a faction; then this will turn into a normal game of Mafia with only one group and one person dying each night.

Refer to this page for my evidence. Also, here's one of the quotes:

Sor, you don't have majority vote yet. If you can persuade those who haven't voted yet, you might have a chance as long as you don't get one more vote. I myself still haven't decided.

I have played Mafia with Peony many times, and usually she does not try this hard to keep someone from being voted out. If it happens, it happens. But the way she asked Søren to defend himself strikes me as odd. She then votes with Soren for Sage. I can see why a Blue Mafia would do this. Del got killed, so if Søren also gets voted out, the Blue Mafia would be left alone. Of course they would fight hard to keep their last partner alive.

Unlike the accusations made so far, this is based on posts rather than clues that could be far more easily misinterpreted.

It's just too suspicious for me NOT to vote for her.

EDIT: The story also makes sense with Peony being Blue Mafia, as the location where Fatch was shot is surmised to be outside his room.

[Cornflower MM]

Note to self: Don't point out simple facts anymore. It will get you killed.

[Eulaliaaa!]

Voting me out is a bad idea. I'm a doctor. I'm just saying that so you can be all like "What a stereotypical Mafia strategy for staying in the game" or "You're being so dramatic you couldn't possibly be Town" or "I'm calling your bluff, liar. Die, Mafia!", but then I can see your reaction after I'm dead and be like "Haha, suckers! I told you so!" And laugh, then cry because I'm out of the game, but also be relieved because I don't have time to this game. Also, because last time I said something like that before I got voted out, I was the Detective.

Run-on sentences

[Cornflower MM]

Oh my. Sowwee, Eul. I'm refraining from voting unless I have to, but I really don't think you're a Mafia. I could be wrong (And likely am, since Sor fooled me) but that's where I stand.

[Skyblade]

Well, I will admit that I am a bit more nervous now, but it's not impossible for Eul to be lying.

@Eulaliaaa! "Doctor" is a bit vague, don't you think? Which doctor are you?

[Eulaliaaa!]

Anti-Blue Doctor, if you want me to be specific.

[Skyblade]

Hmm, ok. I was asking because it makes sense for a Mafia member to make vague claims about being a role to avoid being voted. But to claim a specific role is more risky because the person who actually IS that role could post with "What are you talking about? I'M __, not you".

So, if you're telling the truth, you're the one who saved me on Night 1! Awkward. Hmm. I may or may not believe this claim.

@Gonff the Mousethief
@Groddil
@Aimless Gallivanter
@Lord Ashenwyte
@Rosie Willowwater
@Sagetip
@Peony
@Chipster of Noonvale

Are any of you the Anti-Blue Doctor? I'm trying to see if Eul is telling the truth here.

If I decide to believe Eul's claim, I'm probably going to vote Ash. I'm less sold on Peony as Mafia because if she was, it would have made sense for her to vote Eul out. (Unless Peony and Eul are Red Mafia together? AAAH. I hate this game But if Eul is unlikely to be Mafia, it wouldn't make sense for me to think she's with Peony.)

Ash is both 1) Suspicious and 2) Inactive. A combination of these qualities is good grounds to get someone out. You don't have to worry that someone who isn't posting is Mafia, and even if they were Town it's not like they were helping the game anyway. It's a risk-reward thing.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

Nope, just a regular old citizen. I'm still going for her though, simply because the more she pleads the more I feel as if she is lying.

[Eulaliaaa!]

I'm not pleading. I already said I accepted death and can't wait to rub it in your faces that I was the Doctor

@Skyblade you're welcome about saving you, no problem buddy (unless you're a Mafia. That would be not cool )

[Skyblade]

I'm not thanking you just yet, buddy There's always the chance that you're lying.

Also:

I'm not pleading. I already said I accepted death and can't wait to rub it in your faces that I was the Doctor

You technically are pleading when you claim a role, no matter what you call it That's why I'm leery to believe you.

[Chipster of Noonvale]

I thought the game on the Honeycomb was confusing...

I'm removing my vote...for now.  I may still vote for Eul later, but I'll see...

And no, I'm not the anti-blue doctor.

So, if you're telling the truth, you're the one who saved me on Night 1!

Not necessarily.  You may have been saved by the regular doctor.

[Aimless Gallivanter]

I think eul will be dead either way. with all this attention on her, and revealing she might be the doctor,  it's a death sentence

[Eulaliaaa!]

Yeah, but this way I get to rub it in your faces, which is better than going anything. If I'm going out, I'm gonna have fun on my way!

[Skyblade]

I'm still wary.

I'm still going for her though, simply because the more she pleads the more I feel as if she is lying.

@Gonff the Mousethief  Why so?