Movie/TV show VS Book

[Tiria Wildlough]

It doesn't matter, you can still watch them.

[Marlfox70]

I wanted a Redwall movie <3 had decided it could work after watching the new lion the witch and the wardrobe and how well they did the animals

[Driffle]

We need more episodes of the TV show. Of course books too. I wish Brian Jacques was still alive, WE NEED MORE BOOKS!!  -Driffle

[Lutra]

I really am of the opinion we don't need more books.  I think 23 of a similar formula is more than enough.  Now, tv shows based on a book or two, I wouldn't mind seeing more of.

[georgedepp]

I would love movies. My favourite movies are:
1. Gladiator.
2. Home alone 3.
3. Volcano.
4. The core.
5. The Karate Kid.

[ryanbrian]

Movies are one of my passion to watch every week. I have seen lots of movies but some of my favourite movies are: Home alone 3, Terminator salvation, Mr and Mrs Smith, Final Destination 5 and Paranormal activity.

[2 quid is good]

defo a tv series, thats what started me off, and ep 39 always makes me cry, I mean ALWAYS!

[Redwallfan7]

I love the t.v series. I'm still on the Mattimeo season, though. I think everything (well most of everything) is fairly close to the books.

[2 quid is good]

You're gonna love that series, especially at the end when Matthias goes to Matti "be kind in victory my son" and then he does umm i'll stop cos I don't want to spoil it!

[Robert]

Well ... What if David Jacques, son of Brian, will write Redwall Books ? I know he is an artist, but who knows  And Redwall TV series ... I think Nelvana, will make movies at some Redwall Books 

[shanebob]

I am interested to watch the movie show because i am very tired with reading the book and feel so bad. Movie show is the right way through which you can enjoy your self and pass out the time.

[Redwallfan7]

Who agrees that they should make all of the books into t.v series or a movie? or probably not because I wouldn't want those good books ruined with 3d cg animation it would have to be 2d to be good.

[Lutra]

^ Not all of them.  I think people would get bored of the predictable storyline after about three of them.  There can be too much of a good thing.

[Wydran Riverpaw]

I'd also rather see a movie or TV series than a new book. I wouldn't want Redwall books from another author. I think that adaptations of the books would be fine as long as they stay true to the spirit of Redwall that Brian Jacques created.

A movie might also bring more attention to the books, too. I think that a film would probably be done in CGI, since that seems to be where animation is going now, and I don't mind that. I think it'd be interesting to see the characters created in that way. I just really hope that if a film adaptation is made, it's done well and not as a cheap money-grabbing scheme.

[Søren]

The CGI that is capable now could make a very good movie.  But a book would be good to.  And don't think that I have ruled out that Brian Jaques is dead, because if you remember, The Rouge Crew came out after he died.  Some authors have books that they are waiting to publish and they die and the book gets published by a family member. I think that if a movie is within the budget, it would be the best move, even thug a new book would be nice.