Do you think BJ should have put humans in Redwall?

[WoodlandWarrior]

I like the feel of Redwall as is.  I agree with the majority of the posts that humans would have changed the stories drastically and might have gone so far as to "ruin" them.

Though, as for things like Watership Down or Plague Dogs which have humans, is done in a way where the story is not ruined but is enhanced.  Both are quite sad and moving.

But Redwall, having a medieval feel and having the animals anthropomorphized does set it apart.  Even considering the world at its core is just a medieval setting featuring humanized animals...it does have a distinct and magical feel.  It is really in its own category!