which character deaths made you sad?

[Ungatt Trunn]

I wasn't too sad with Hugo's death...I dunno....just me.

Norther was I. For some reason to me, Hugo's death seemed just like...another death, I guess.

[Vilu Daskar]

none of them

[Tam and Martin]

really? None of the death's made you sad?

[Ungatt Trunn]

none of them

Are you sure?

[Vilu Daskar]

none of them

Are you sure?

Yes

[Maudie]

Well, saddest deaths?:

Finnbar Galedeep

Shogg.

[Sailears]

Main times I cried (even upon rereading)

- Rose
- Bragoon and Saro (best bittersweet ending in the entire series, on par with Rose)
- Piknim
- Jukka and Fleetscut
- Sayna, then Luke and co.
- Cregga  (so amazing; happy tears )
- Rockjaw Grang (WHY )
- Finnbar Galedeep
- Mother Mellus
- Shogg

That's all I can think of off the top of my head.Probably a ton more- I'm building myself up to reread all the books so I'll probably discover several more that make me cry.

EDIT: OH MY GOODNESS, how could I forget - SKARLATH!

[Dannflower Reguba]

Main times I cried (even upon rereading)

- Rose
- Bragoon and Saro (best bittersweet ending in the entire series, on par with Rose)
- Piknim
- Jukka and Fleetscut
- Sayna, then Luke and co.
- Cregga  (so amazing; happy tears )
- Rockjaw Grang (WHY )
- Finnbar Galedeep
- Mother Mellus
- Shogg

That's all I can think of off the top of my head.Probably a ton more- I'm building myself up to reread all the books so I'll probably discover several more that make me cry.

EDIT: OH MY GOODNESS, how could I forget - SKARLATH!

That's pretty much exactly how I feel... Sayna is Martin's mother right?

Add Russa Nodrey for me though.

[Ferrousferret]

Hugo's death was much sadder in the show- one of the few things they did well, I guess.

I will say that it takes a heck of a lot for a movie to get me to cry, let alone a book. I can count on one hand every time a book has gotten a legitimate emotional reaction out of me- and several of them were from one series in particular (not Redwall). Then again, they are children's stories, so you can't really go all too dark with them. Still, tragic, well handled deaths in Redwall:

-Methuselah
-Queen Warbeak
-sad close calls in Salamandastron towards the end with that fever storyline
-Rose
-Felldoh
-Veil Sixclaw
-Piknim
-Russa Nodrey
-Luke
-Bragoon & Saro
-Flandor

[MeadowR]

Rose had a shocking, sudden death - the one I most remember until I get reading again.

[Sailears]

Oh my, and how could I forget Russa!

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Roze'z. Every time.

[Leatho Shellhound]

Hugo's death was much sadder in the show- one of the few things they did well, I guess.

I will say that it takes a heck of a lot for a movie to get me to cry, let alone a book. I can count on one hand every time a book has gotten a legitimate emotional reaction out of me- and several of them were from one series in particular (not Redwall). Then again, they are children's stories, so you can't really go all too dark with them. Still, tragic, well handled deaths in Redwall:

-Methuselah
-Queen Warbeak
-sad close calls in Salamandastron towards the end with that fever storyline
-Rose
-Felldoh
-Veil Sixclaw
-Piknim
-Russa Nodrey
-Luke
-Bragoon & Saro
-Flandor

Yes, that's how I feel too!

[Tam and Martin]

Hugo's death was much sadder in the show- one of the few things they did well, I guess.

I will say that it takes a heck of a lot for a movie to get me to cry, let alone a book. I can count on one hand every time a book has gotten a legitimate emotional reaction out of me- and several of them were from one series in particular (not Redwall). Then again, they are children's stories, so you can't really go all too dark with them. Still, tragic, well handled deaths in Redwall:

-Methuselah
-Queen Warbeak
-sad close calls in Salamandastron towards the end with that fever storyline
-Rose
-Felldoh
-Veil Sixclaw
-Piknim
-Russa Nodrey
-Luke
-Bragoon & Saro
-Flandor

Yes, that's how I feel too!

How you feel about what? Hugo, Character's dying, or the people who he mentioned who died?

[Emperor Ublaz]

I hated when Veil died. I just felt that he should have lived on and...you know, became Abbey warrior or something.