What's the most Tragic Event in Redwall

[rachel25]

I know there's a topic called What deaths in Redwall made you sad but this is a topic about events not just deaths but anything in Redwall like when Saint. Ninians had to be burnt down. When they had to sink Wunship and so on
so post away 

[Emperor Ublaz]

Dinjer LIVED!!!! NOOOOOOO!!!!!


...Haha! Just kidding...maybe


It was sad when Mother Mellus was killed by Captain Slipp.

[Ungatt Trunn]

It was sad when Mother Mellus was killed by Captain Slipp.

Sounds familiar, but which book did that happen in?

By far, the most tragic event was when Rose died!

[Firehawke]

I also think that the death of Cregga and the circumstances that led up to it were sad

[Emperor Ublaz]

It was sad when Mother Mellus was killed by Captain Slipp.

Sounds familiar, but which book did that happen in?

The Bellmaker...I think. I'll look it up *flips through book*
Yeah, it was the Bellmaker.

[Iamthatis]

When Mattimeo gets taken from Redwall Abbey I almost started crying when I got to that part. Thank Martin he is back

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Rose'z deaz. It getz me every time!

[Emperor Ublaz]

That was sad, too. I choked up...

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Ah liked 'ov zey vent aboot it in ze T.V zhov.

[WildDoogyPlumm]

Oh jeez...hard question...
Butty Wopscutt (spelling?)'s death was devastating...this is horrible but I also realized that most likely Gulo, being the cannibal he is, would have eaten Butty...     

[Shadowed One]

Never thought about that.

Either Rose's death, or Finnbarr Galedeep's death.

[rachel25]

Finnbarr Galedeep  and the burning of Saint. Ninians 

[Emperor Ublaz]

Finnbarr!!! NOOOOO!!!!

(My thought process during that scene)

[rachel25]

I cry 

[Tam and Martin]

ROSE! That was soooooo sad!