Rose's Death - Poll

[MeadowR]

I found the way she died so sudden and shocking. I didn't get really upset so I had to vote 'neutral'.

[The Skarzs]

Yeh

[The Shade]

I'm still on neutral grounds.

[The Skarzs]

How do you get 'neutral' ground into dust?

[rachel25]

I liked her, but I didn't cry. The only Redwall books I cried at were, Bellmaker, Loamhedge, Mossflower, Legend of Luke (I howled reading the end of that one) and Salamanderstron. There were probably others, but I can't remember.

[Ungatt Trunn]

I liked her, but I didn't cry. The only Redwall books I cried at were, Bellmaker, Loamhedge, Mossflower, Legend of Luke (I howled reading the end of that one) and Salamanderstron. There were probably others, but I can't remember.

You howled when you read the end of Legend Of Luke? Why?

[Russa Nodrey]

I found the way she died so sudden and shocking. I didn't get really upset so I had to vote 'neutral'.

Yeah, I voted "neutral".

[Vilu Daskar]

I didn't care that she died

[Wylder Treejumper]

I think it was really tragic she died. It is probably one of the saddest things I have ever read. But I really liked Rose as a character, maybe because she reminded me of someone I used to know... Their personalities are remarkably similar. Also, the effect it had on Martin made it doubly tragic.

[Vilu Daskar]

I didn't like her

[Banya Streamdog]

 I almost cried. It was so sad!!!  I also loves the character!

[Deyna the Warrior]

I have p not read the firt ones yet.. But not too fond. Of her in the show. Cornflower on the other hand was amazing! Genius! Only reason rose's death wAs a teensiest bit sad cuz Martin liked her. And that seemed a tad sudden to, going from hidden like to "OMG rose don't leave! Nuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!"

I'll either vote neutral or sucky character.

Well, people in real life do that a lot too. Half because they might have been hiding feelings, but also half because until they're gone, people don't realize how much they loved them.

[Tim Churchmouse]

I must say, when I read the book those many years ago, I was rather sad but not enough to make me cry. When I watched the TV series, it was so beautifully sad (especially the last song *sniff sniff*) I cried my heart out for a couple of minutes.

[Delthion]

I didn't like and it made me sad, but it did not make me cry.

[Jasper]

Neutral. She was a good character and all, but a good bit of the book was hinting at her death, making it not much of a surprise for me. I liked her a good deal more in the TV show, but still not enough to cry or care too much. Also, I think the fact that all of the characters are animals and not human is the main reason for my neutrality. I simply have trouble building up much emotion for a character who is a troublesome rodent in real life.