Woodlanders that we wish had lived (SPOILER ALERT)

[Aimless Gallivanter]

Ill take a look through all those books later and see which one I was talking about haha thank you guys

[Ashleg]

It's not Graylunk, it's Grubbage from Triss. Graylunk was only in The Pearls of Lutra as a skeleton.

They did go into depth with Graylunk's story, though, so we were able to tell how he was before he died.
I think it was him.

[Jetthebinturong]

He never ran a ferry service though, he stayed at the abbey after a fight with his friend, reformed, then left, fell down a hole and died.

[Ashleg]

Maybe they got two characters mixed up.

...And plus...Wow, Graylunk's story is depressing when you put it like that. >.<

[Vilu Deskar]

Log-a-Log in Mattimeo. Also Graylunk's story in Pearls of Lutra was pretty much what Jet said.

[Grond]

He never ran a ferry service though, he stayed at the abbey after a fight with his friend, reformed, then left, fell down a hole and died.

I don't know if he reformed per say. Its more so he came to the abbey with a horrific head wound/skull fracture and was in intense pain. All he could or did basically was whine and moan about the pain. The Abbey got fed up with him but Fermdale took pity and took him up to the attic to live with her. He stayed there a few days and left and then died in that hole/cavern. Im not sure he reformed it seems to have been a case of the pain being so bad that it was all he could think of and thus was not capable of getting up to "vermin activities" even if he had wanted to do so.

[gojuchrisa]

I don't know if he reformed per say. Its more so he came to the abbey with a horrific head wound/skull fracture and was in intense pain. All he could or did basically was whine and moan about the pain. The Abbey got fed up with him but Fermdale took pity and took him up to the attic to live with her. He stayed there a few days and left and then died in that hole/cavern. Im not sure he reformed it seems to have been a case of the pain being so bad that it was all he could think of and thus was not capable of getting up to "vermin activities" even if he had wanted to do so.

I could double check but i believe it said in the book that he rambled about not wanting to cause harm (the wrath of Ublaz) to fall upon Fermalde, so i would say partly reformed, in part due to his brain damage/pain

[Sanddunes]

Rose would have had a higher chance of surviving if Martin the warrior was written before  Mossflower. The story would have been the same with or with out her

[Ashleg]

Why would you say that? Badrang could just as easily have killed her, no matter when the story took place.
And Martin the Warrior does take place before Mossflower.

If Brian wrote that book before Mossflower, it doesn't mean anything about the survival of Rose. He could and probably would still have killed her off. I don't follow.

[The Skarzs]

In my opinion, I don't think Rose would have lived if Brian had written Martin the Warrior before Mossflower. However, what I think is more likely is that Rose may not have even existed, and we would have seen a different story. If anything would have changed, it would be Martin's story that he tells in Mosslfower about his past.

[Captain Tammo]

Now that would be a wild thing to discover: Rose never existed

What about our dear friend from The Long Patrol with the gruffness of a stubborn badger in a sulk, Russa Nodrey? She was one of my favorites! Also one of the first "good-guy" deaths I ever read about in the Redwall series (LP was my first book), so it had a certain weight to it.

[The Skarzs]

Oh yes, her death certainly did hit a blow.

[Ashleg]

I forgot she died.

[The Skarzs]

SHAME UPON YOU AND YOUR GOAT.

[Nadaz, voice of the host]

I remember that she died but how did she die? Was it from exhaustion after the march with Tammo?