POLL: If These Badgers were in a fight, who would win

[LT Sandpaw]

Vilaya was the Sable Queen right?

[Hickory]

Yup.

Zwilt was the better character. Neither of them were spectacular, but Vilaya was a token bad guy leader. Zwilt was a little bit cooler.

[Ashleg]

MALKARISS SCORES TEN OUTTA TEN FOR BEING THE CREEPIER CHARACTER.

[LT Sandpaw]

I dunno about that Ashes, the argument could be made that Slagar was the creepier character, he was certainly the most fleshed out. Malkariss was just Empire building, and while I do believe Slave owning is terrible I don't think it makes him inherently evil or creepy. What made Slagar so great and freaky was his willingness to go through so much, and harbor that grudge for so long before finally enacting his revenge. Not just by killing his enemies, but hurting them in the worse way he possible could.

In a way Slagar was brilliant, in a twisted way. Every bit of his plan, from killing off his crew, too kidnapping Mattimeo, to becoming Malkariss' paw above the underground kingdom, was very impressive and the work of a mastermind.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

I really love Slagar just because of how he connected Redwall and Mattimeo. I did always wonder what happened to Chickenhound, and when he was announced as Slagar, it just made me really happy. Plus He was awesome in the TV show. All around a creepy, eerie, but wholesome villain, and for sure one of my favorites.

[Lord Daskar]

I haven't read Mattimeo in a while, but I have seen the TV show more recently. Based off of that I say Slagar.

[LT Sandpaw]

We see Chickenhound get supposedly killed by Asmodeous in Redwall. I was sure he was dead when I was reading the books. My only complaint for Slagar was that he somehow knew what was going on in Redwall long before he sent Vitch in to spy on them.
Somehow he knew about Mattimeo, and I don't think he was invited to that baby shower.

But that has nothing to do with the poll.

[Ashleg]

I like them equally so I'm not gonna vote.

-Feragho the Swartt

[Delthion]

Swartt Sixclaw, much craftier.

[Lord Daskar]

I remember Ferahgo better than Swartt. So I said Ferahgo.

[Gonff the Mousethief]

Since Salamadastron is my least favorite Redwall book, mostly because Ferhago seemed like a very week villain by the end, I will have to say Swartt  is better. I mean, he was much more memorable.

[alexandre]

We need a tie breaker.

[Ashleg]

Fine! I'll vote.

[The Skarzs]

Most definitely Sawney Rath.

[Hickory]

Most definitely Sawney Rath.