Your least favourite Redwall book

[The Shade]

How do so many people dislike Loamhedge? That's a fantastically written book!

Because it's a mess. I've already said what I think and so have others. Reread our reasons and take it in.

Loamhedge also unintentially insults those handicapet too.

I really don't think Brian ment it to be like that, but yeah, it kinda does in a way.

[Ungatt Trunn]

How do so many people dislike Loamhedge? That's a fantastically written book!

Because it's a mess. I've already said what I think and so have others. Reread our reasons and take it in.

Loamhedge also unintentially insults those handicapet too.

I really don't think Brian ment it to be like that, but yeah, it kinda does in a way.

Yea.

[The Shade]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

Doomwyte was okay for me; a little chaotic, but still intresting.

[The Shade]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

Doomwyte was okay for me; a little chaotic, but still intresting.

What was your worst? Loamhedge?

[redwallgurl]

How do so many people dislike Loamhedge? That's a fantastically written book!

Because it's a mess. I've already said what I think and so have others. Reread our reasons and take it in.

Loamhedge also unintentially insults those handicapet too.

Does that automatically make it a bad book? Loamhedge had many different parts in the story to keep it moving along with all the different parties. And I don't think it insults the handicap at all. It just has a handicap beast in it and gives a little insight about what people in wheel chairs have to deal with. Loamhedge has many emotion jerking parts which in my opinion make it a good book in general.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

Doomwyte was okay for me; a little chaotic, but still intresting.

What was your worst? Loamhedge?

Actually, I really liked Loamhedge. My least favourare Redwall book was Marlfox.

[Tam and Martin]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

Doomwyte was okay for me; a little chaotic, but still intresting.

What was your worst? Loamhedge?

Actually, I really liked Loamhedge. My least favourare Redwall book was Marlfox.

I think this is one of the first times I disagree with you. In my opinion, Loamhedge is a lot worse that Marlfox.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Anyway, I voted Doomwyte. The only part that really interested me was learning about Gonff's family.

Doomwyte was okay for me; a little chaotic, but still intresting.

What was your worst? Loamhedge?

Actually, I really liked Loamhedge. My least favourare Redwall book was Marlfox.

I think this is one of the first times I disagree with you. In my opinion, Loamhedge is a lot worse that Marlfox.

Allot of people disagree with me about Marlfox, believe me.

[Faiyloe]

I really dislike "The Rogue Crew" What was up with the blood thirsty otters.

[Tam and Martin]

I really dislike "The Rogue Crew" What was up with the blood thirsty otters.

I loved the otters themselves but how they acted was totally out of character.

[Ungatt Trunn]

I really dislike "The Rogue Crew" What was up with the blood thirsty otters.

I loved the otters themselves but how they acted was totally out of character.

Same here.

[Dannflower Reguba]

Why do people have to keep on asking Ungatt what his least favorite book is?  I swear people ask him that just to tick me off.   

Anyway, I concur about Rogue Crew, one of my least favorite in the series, it ruined otters for me, and the ship was a bit much for me. 

[Ungatt Trunn]

Why do people have to keep on asking Ungatt what his least favorite book is?  I swear people ask him that just to tick me off.   

Its the question of the year.

[Royaler]

Eulalia is the worst for me