Rose (yes, Rose again): Did she actually die?

[Dannflower Reguba]

Oh my gosh! Seriously!

@Flandor If you don't like this "Nitpicking" as you seem to call it. Than go somewhere else and post.

@Felldoh One, never said she was to be buried... and what does that matter anyway? TO BE BURUIED? And did you read what I said?

"Ahhh. But that's the thing. He didn't say outright that she was DEAD... And besides. he was young, he is no authority on death yet."

I still stand on this, High and dry even after you come storming after me..... Why do you HAVE to try and force your syniscism on me? Or others that beleive this way?

[psybox]

"Ahhh. But that's the thing. He didn't say outright that she was DEAD... And besides. he was young, he is no authority on death yet."

it didn't say outright that martin has purple fur, so is he purple furred?

[Dannflower Reguba]

That's taking things way out of cotext... And actually I think It says his fur is brown... Main characters appearances are usually described to the reader because these books were made for blind children.

[psybox]

they do say he has brown fur, but that implies (key word: implies) he doesn't have purple fur, it still never said he doesn't have purple fur, and creatures can have both purple fur and brown fur.  Sorry if that sounds mocking, but sometimes it's better to trust in implications rather than believe that an author will give the reader every single detail available.

[Dannflower Reguba]

Again, it's your own choice. If you want to imagine Martin having purple fur (which is taking things a little too far) then that is your choice... But that is a bit more insane than imagining that Rose lived.

[Felldoh154]

I disagree, Martin definetly had purple fur and rose died

[Dannflor]

I disagree, Martin definetly had purple fur and rose died

I agree

[Felldoh154]

Oh ya, and brome was a werewolf hybrid

[Redwallfan7]

I thought that the t.v show was way cooler than the book, even though I liked the book. I'm editing this post so I don't cause controversy. I didn't like some of the changes that they made, and again, I enjoyed the book. Even though the book is way too sad to be in my top favorites anymore. To get back on the subject, I believe Rose died physically, but was still alive in spirit.

[psybox]

Again, it's your own choice. If you want to imagine Martin having purple fur (which is taking things a little too far) then that is your choice... But that is a bit more insane than imagining that Rose lived.

you are missing the point, i wasn't saying that he did, i was saying according to your argument martin has purple fur.

[Felldoh154]

Heh heh, clever 

[Dannflower Reguba]

I never once said anything that suggests that. You guys are tking my words WAY out of context and sensability, and until you grow up and put them back in context. I'm not even going to bother debating it.

[Felldoh154]

Saying rose is alive takes it way out of context to ya know

[psybox]

again, i am not saying that he has purple fur, or that you come up with insane ideas, i am saying that your argument is incorrect because, as i stated, if not saying something happens make something happen, people could come up with insane theories like martin having purple fur. 

sometimes it's better to trust in implications rather than believe that an author will give the reader every single detail available.

[Felldoh154]

Psybox is good at this