who would win?

[daskar666]

It's your interpretation so if you want you can leave him.
But I'll just note that the main villain in the final battle of High Rhulain was Pitru (IMO Riggu Felis is still the main antagonist of course).

[Captain Tammo]

Point taken. Anyway, which villain would come out on top?

[Captain Tammo]

Ok all you redwall fans, who would win,

Flicheye vs. Painted Ones

[Tiria Wildlough]

O i changed it but I left Kharanjul in there because he was the villain at the final battle. If you guys still want him off the list, I'll take him out for you

Vallug Bowbeast was NOT the main villain in Tagguerung. You could just say 'The Juska'.

[Log-a-Log]

Flitchaye vs. Painted ones, hmm.. I'd have to say the Flitchaye because there herbs would knock out the Painted ones before they could do anything

[Dotti]

Hmm, tough call.  If the Flitcheye had time to deploy their sleeping gas, they would win hands down.  If not, I think it would really depend on who had the best leader.  Both are tribes of "savages" and are portrayed as unorganized and not overly burdened with wits. 

[Log-a-Log]

Yeah, they're both pretty cowardly

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Ok all you redwall fans, who would win,

Flicheye vs. Painted Ones

The Flitchaye, o' courze! Bezidez bein' Weasels, they wid zimply uze their herbz an' the painted onez wid faw right out o' their treez. Thoze tha' werenae killed upon impact with the ground wid be killed by the Flitchaye.

Flitchaye!

[Redwall Musician]

Somehow I knew you were going to say that. But yes, weasels win.

[Skalrag of Marshank]

I think the Flitchaye would win, because they have the weird knock-out herb thingamajiggers. Unless the herbs took too long to take effect...

[James Gryphon]

It depends on the environment -- if the Flitchaye enter the Painted Ones' domain, they're very likely to lose, but if the Painted Ones entered Flitchaye territory, they would perish. Both of the sides have too strong a home advantage for the other one to prevail.

In a "neutral environment", the Flitchaye wouldn't likely have the time to set up their knockout herbs, and the Painted Ones should be able to take them out by sheer numbers.

Since this seems to be resolved: Imagine Mossflower country. Verdauga Greeneyes, Ruler of Kotir, and his daughter Tsarmina have just crushed the woodlander rebellion, and forced a negotiated peace -- his army will protect the woodlanders, in exchange for a regular portion of their produce.

However, just several miles away, a certain horse-drawn cart crashes to a halt right in front of St. Ninian's. Their leader immediately begins to scout out the countryside. The first rat, Fangburn, that finds his way to Kotir is promptly executed. With the newcomers' element of surprise lost, Lord Greeneyes marshals his forces as the invading troops re-discover the building and report back to their base.

Does the infamous Scourge cut into the heart of Mossflower, or does the Master of the Thousand Eyes finally put an end to his rampage?

[Nightfire]

Plugg Firetail vs. Slagar the Cruel.

Now THAT, I would like to see!

[Log-a-Log]

I feel Cluny the Scourge would win because he seems younger, more fit, and and in better shape to command than Verdauga. It would be an epic war, though.

[James Gryphon]

Well, one thing to remember is that this isn't Verdauga as in Mossflower -- it's right after he crushed the rebellion led by Barkstripe, the first one.

So while he might not be in his prime, it's before his sickness and he should still be in very good shape.

[Tiria Wildlough]

^^That's true.
I would love to see Vizka Longtooth fight Tsarmina. Tsarmina would probably win, because of her size, but foxes are not all that smaller than cats, and Vizka would do a lot of damage with his mace and chain.
Also, Ungatt Trunn and Tsarmina! That would be an epic fight.
^^Any comments?