Which book is better!

[Tam and Martin]

It just didn't seem as good as the others. I didn't really like some of the people like for Meldrum the Magnificent, he just didn't seem like a normal hare. Urgan Nagru and Silvamord weren't the best villains (to me). Mariel annd Dandin are okay characters, Glokkpod is one of my least favorite birds and so on.

I do love the part that takes place at Redwall with Slipp and Blaggut, Tarquin, and Mother Mellus.

Overall I just like Mariel of Redwall better just because of the storyline.

[Dannflower Reguba]

The Bellmaker by a long shot! Hated Mariel.

[WildDoogyPlumm]

I liked both, but Mariel of Redwall was my favorite of those two.  It seemed more suspenseful and fast-paced, and Gabool was a very interesting antagonist.

[Tam and Martin]

I definately agree with you Doogy.

[Slagar Mc Muffin]

agree also,i didnt really liked urgan nagru ,silvamord was ok

[Captain Tammo]

THE BELLMAKER!!
Mariel was amazing don't get me wrong, but there's something about Joseph the bellmaker that's just.... Awesome!!!

[phoenixfoden]

the bellmaker was dissapointing for me,after reading it i started to wonder if brian knew what a wolf was lol.mariel of redwall was awesome i loved reading that book and loved gabool!

[Tam and Martin]

Mariel of Redwall:6
The Bellmaker:5

MoR wins!

Poll change

To me it's Lord Brocktree. The Legend of Luke'sBook Two was really exciting but I didn't like Book One and Three.

[Redwaller]

I really liked Lord Brocktree, but Legend of Luke was better

[Dannflower Reguba]

Lord Brocktree was quite a bit better because Luke's story was so ridiculously sad! I ABHOR sad stories! Who invented Tradgedies!? I'm going to kill his ghost!

[redwallgurl]

I liked Lord brocktree better. I guess it was more Redwally for my style. And Legend of Luke was sadand a bit more mature than I'm used to.

[Ungatt Trunn]

Lord Brocktree is defunautly better.

[Tam and Martin]

Even though there are only a few votes I think it's ready for a:

POLL CHANGE

The Legend of Luke:2
Lord Brocktree:4
The winner is Lord Brocktree

Marlfox gets our vote. I liked The Outcast of Redwall's characters but the storyline was a little dull.

[Captain Tammo]

Mm... Outcast. It was just soon different compared to the other books. A vermin main character, the only other book close to that kind of viewpoint is Taggerung

[Tam and Martin]

I also like that.