Which book is better!

[Tam and Martin]

I decided to make a changing poll of which Redwall book is better. This is my first time doing a changing poll so I am not sure how well it will turn out. To me Salamandastron is better.

[Mad Maudie]

Long patrol!

[Redwaller]

Salamandastron.

[Leatho Shellhound]

I don't know, I like them both.

[Frost]

Granted any poll on opinion will have very polarized sides...

I lean to Salamandastron, only because that's the book that turned me onto the series in middle school. Something about a badger in armor, standing in front of a massive, Kilimanjaro-esque mountain drew me in; Master Jacques' writing did the rest.

[Captain Tammo]

THE LONG PATROL it was the greatest book in the series (next to the legend of Luke of course) because it was the story of what I call a "background character". What I mean by this is that Tammo, even though he was visited by Martin, he was simply a new recruit. He had no special powers or skills. He was simply an average character on an extraordinary journey, this made the story much better and realistic in my opinion.

[Tam and Martin]

I agree with you Captain Tammo. I like how Tammo (The Character) went through being a new recruit to a veteran of war. But, to me, I still think Salamandastron is better.

[321tumbler]

I can't say because it has been a long time since I read Salamandastron.

[Tam and Martin]

Salamandastron:5
The Long Patrol:6

The Long Patrol wins

Poll change!

I choose Mariel of Redwall. The Bellmaker was a little boring...

[Leatho Shellhound]

Bellmaker all the way!!!

[Rusvul]

Bellmaker, I'd say.

[Redwaller]

Mariel

[Redwallfan7]

Mariel of Redwall  gets my vote.

[Tam and Martin]

To me, The Bellmaker is sortof boring.

[Leatho Shellhound]

To me, The Bellmaker is sortof boring.

How can you say that!!!! Bellmaker was a great read!!!