Should there be guns in Redwall

[rachel25]

I can imagine romsca with a loaded flintlock close at hand

me too!

[phoenixfoden]

I can imagine romsca with a loaded flintlock close at hand

me too!

probly the best loot on a boarded ship so she kept it for herself

[Captain Tammo]

Well, guns and redwall dont really go hand in hand in my head because it is taking two different eras and combining them. BUT, there are geniuses out there who build a first everything. I would be open to the idea, but if it was used in a controlled maner

[rachel25]

Well, guns and redwall dont really go hand in hand in my head because it is taking two different eras and combining them. BUT, there are geniuses out there who build a first everything. I would be open to the idea, but if it was used in a controlled maner

me too I wouldn't want just everyone to have a gun that would ruin the series BUT if as you said it was used in a controlled matter such as a handful of creatures ever had an early kind of guns then yes I would like that

[Rusvul]

Yah. I actually wouldn't mind having a flintlock pistol IRL, but  I don't want any kind of revolver or machine gun. My opinion of guns: Flintlocks and earlier are cool, anything later is not something I want to be involved with, except maybe if it was directly tied to a flintlock somehow.

[Tam and Martin]

Yah. I actually wouldn't mind having a flintlock pistol IRL, but  I don't want any kind of revolver or machine gun. My opinion of guns: Flintlocks and earlier are cool, anything later is not something I want to be involved with, except maybe if it was directly tied to a flintlock somehow.

Agreed. If it was a big killing machine gun or a huge missile or anything like that, it would ruin the series.

[The Shade]

What about pepper bombs?? I'm sure that counts...

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Yah. I actually wouldn't mind having a flintlock pistol IRL, but  I don't want any kind of revolver or machine gun. My opinion of guns: Flintlocks and earlier are cool, anything later is not something I want to be involved with, except maybe if it was directly tied to a flintlock somehow.

Agreed. If it was a big killing machine gun or a huge missile or anything like that, it would ruin the series.

Alzae agreed. Zome gun zat juzt 'ad vone or zae zhotz in it might be okay, but nae zomezin' like a machine gun. Ah liked ze vay zey did it in Ze Vind In Ze Villovz. Mayhapz ye could juzt 'ave zome characterz tryin' tae figure oot gunpovder...? Makez for a major Fan Fiction ztory me zinkz...

[UNKN0WN]

Question: Should there be guns in Redwall?
Answer: Yes.

[HeadInAnotherGalaxy]

Aw! But nay, zere zhould nae be gunz in Redwall.

[Redwaller]

NO! Absolutely not, and that squirrel is ugly with a gun.

[npa99]

I agree with all the other posts, guns would ruin Redwall, but your fanfic sounds like something I would read.

[The Shade]

NO! Absolutely not, and that squirrel is ugly with a gun.

YOU were the one that made the modern redwall rp!!!

[rachel25]

I agree with all the other posts, guns would ruin Redwall, but your fanfic sounds like something I would read.

thanks here's a link if you want to read what I've written so far
~Finding You~

[Redwaller]

NO! Absolutely not, and that squirrel is ugly with a gun.

YOU were the one that made the modern redwall rp!!!

RPs and Fanfics are okay, but others say that they would have liked Brian to put guns.